Almost a year ago, I chronicled the journey of two young scrumhalves and their attempts to further their careers. At that point, Rhodri Williams was a few short months out from starting in Wales's Junior World Cup march to the final, had started two Heineken Cup games for Scarlets scoring two tries in their impressive unbeaten start to European rugby, and was justly rewarded with a place in Warren Gatland's international squad. Conversely, Kieran Marmion, despite an extra year out from U20 level, had started a full year for Connacht in the Heineken Cup and Pro 12 was not part of Joe Schmidt's 41 man squad announced for 2013's end of year tests.
What a difference a year makes eh?
Since that time, Marmion participated in every game for Connacht, eventually forcing his way into Ireland squads and finally being capped against Argentina this summer. There is no doubting that the Marmion of October 2014 is a better player than the October 2013 version. His slow rise has come about through the benefit of playing consistently against top level players in the Heineken Cup and Pro 12, and getting better coaching, both from increased resources at Connacht, and the meticulous attention to detail of Joe Schmidt, and his own dedication and extra training that he undergoes on a weekly basis.
Marmion is fully deserving of a place in Ireland's squad, and will be pushing for a matchday spot. But what of Rhodri Williams? Williams made his Welsh debut against Tonga that November, coming on as a replacement. That is where the rise finished however. Williams lost his Scarlets place to first, Gareth Davies, and then Aled Davies being relegated to 3rd choice Scarlet's scrumhalf. Gareth Davies was in fantastic form, finishing as the league's top try scorer. Rhodri Williams however, only made a handful of Pro12 starts from then on, with all of his remaining Heineken Cup appearances coming as a sub, much like the majority of his Pro 12 caps last season. He did manage to make Wales's 6 Nations squad, and has a grand total of 3 replacement caps for Wales.
Despite Williams's fall in Scarlets, Gatland curiously continues to pick him, although he may now get his chance given that both of the Davies's in Scarlet's ranks are now injured.
So I ask the question again? Is is better to throw young players in the deep end, or is their development better suited to easing them into it?
To read the original article click here, and note that other players mentioned have also had interesting years. Tom Prydie is back in the Wales squad, James Coughlan is now in Pro D2, Aaron Cruden has had recent disciplinary problems, Victor Vito is now back in the New Zealand squad ahead of Steven Luatua while Scotland's Mark Bennett had a dreadful season, but is now shining after another year's experience. Danny Cipriani was denied his place in the England squad today, although he has been included in the previous year, while Kurtley Beale is in even more trouble with the ARU.
Wednesday 22 October 2014
Tuesday 21 October 2014
Takeaways from the Irish Squad Announcement
For those who haven't seen it, this is the Irish Squad for the November Internationals v South Africa, Australia and Georgia.
Looseheads: Jack McGrath, James Cronin, Dave Kilcoyne.
Hookers: Rory Best, Richardt Strauss, Sean Cronin.
Tightheads: Mike Ross, Nathan White, Rodney Ah You, Stephen Archer.
Loosehead Lock: Devin Toner, Dave Foley.
Tighthead Lock: Paul O'Connell, Mike McCarthy.
Blindside Flanker: Peter O'Mahony (8), Rhys Ruddock, Robbie Diack (8).
Openside Flanker: Chris Henry (8), Tommy O'Donnell, Dominic Ryan
No. 8: Jamie Heaslip.
Scrumhalves: Conor Murray, Kieran Marmion, Eoin Reddan.
Outhalves: Jonathan Sexton, Ian Madigan (12), Ian Keatley.
Wingers: Tommy Bowe, Simon Zebo, Craig Gilroy.
Inside Centres: Gordon D'Arcy, Stuart Olding.
Outside Centres: Jared Payne (15), Robbie Henshaw (15).
Fullbacks: Rob Kearney, Felix Jones, Darragh Leader (11-14)
A number of things caught my eye from this announcement, but pre announcement there was a big campaign for the likes of Duncan Casey and Dave Foley to be included over players familar to the squad.
If there is one thing we have learned since Joe Schmidt has taken over, is that he will always favour those familar to his plans and system over those new to it. Form doesn't mean a huge amount when it's comparing a newcomer to a previous fixture in the squad. He's brought players in, and left them on the periphery to learn his ways before giving them a shot, and he will continue to do that.
This most likely spells the end of some players hopes of being included in the World Cup squad, unless they spend time around the squad in the next month.
A 37 man squad is a strange number of players, especially when you look at the lack of player in some positions, notably number 8 and wing, while a plethora of options at blindside and tighthead prop.
What's notable is that there are four tighthead props involved, and that one of them isn't highly rated youngster Tadhg Furlong. I've also decided I am not going to criticise those named in this post, no matter how much I want to.
The next major talking point revolves around an in form outsider, and an out of form, slightly injured formerly favoured player. I think it's very notable that Ian Keatley has been chosen ahead of Paddy Jackson, one because not many saw it coming, but mostly because the influence of Les Kiss on the Ulster set up would have expected to bring in more Ulster faces. Instead, players like Jackson, Cave, Wilson, McCloskey and Declan Fitzpatrick miss out. Fitzpatrick may be permanently injured, but he was the one time hope of Irish tightheads, and now there are at least 4 options probably ahead of him.
It's also intriguing to note that the first real squad where a successor to Brian O'Driscoll can be found features a grand total of 0 natural outside centres. Of the players in the squad who have played professional rugby at 13, three are fullbacks - Robbie Henshaw, Jared Payne and Darragh Leader, two are wingers - Tommy Bowe and Craig Gilroy, one is an outhalf - Ian Madigan, and two inside centres - Gordon D'Arcy and Stuart Olding.
Despite this curveball, the announcement of two other fullbacks in the squad, while only three wingers, suggest that Payne and Henshaw are the de facto 13s, Leader is a back 3 cover and the wingers stay out wide.
A final congratulatory note to Darragh Leader's inclusion. He may not get any gametime, but it's clear that his involvement will only benefit him in the long run. A quiet guy that needs to come out of his shell more, will only develop with this confidence boost, and given the improvements Henshaw and Marmion have made to their games since being involved with Schmidt, I've no doubt that Leader will make similar strides which can only benefit the player, his province and maybe Ireland in the future.
Looseheads: Jack McGrath, James Cronin, Dave Kilcoyne.
Hookers: Rory Best, Richardt Strauss, Sean Cronin.
Tightheads: Mike Ross, Nathan White, Rodney Ah You, Stephen Archer.
Loosehead Lock: Devin Toner, Dave Foley.
Tighthead Lock: Paul O'Connell, Mike McCarthy.
Blindside Flanker: Peter O'Mahony (8), Rhys Ruddock, Robbie Diack (8).
Openside Flanker: Chris Henry (8), Tommy O'Donnell, Dominic Ryan
No. 8: Jamie Heaslip.
Scrumhalves: Conor Murray, Kieran Marmion, Eoin Reddan.
Outhalves: Jonathan Sexton, Ian Madigan (12), Ian Keatley.
Wingers: Tommy Bowe, Simon Zebo, Craig Gilroy.
Inside Centres: Gordon D'Arcy, Stuart Olding.
Outside Centres: Jared Payne (15), Robbie Henshaw (15).
Fullbacks: Rob Kearney, Felix Jones, Darragh Leader (11-14)
A number of things caught my eye from this announcement, but pre announcement there was a big campaign for the likes of Duncan Casey and Dave Foley to be included over players familar to the squad.
Familiarity
If there is one thing we have learned since Joe Schmidt has taken over, is that he will always favour those familar to his plans and system over those new to it. Form doesn't mean a huge amount when it's comparing a newcomer to a previous fixture in the squad. He's brought players in, and left them on the periphery to learn his ways before giving them a shot, and he will continue to do that.
This most likely spells the end of some players hopes of being included in the World Cup squad, unless they spend time around the squad in the next month.
A 37 man squad is a strange number of players, especially when you look at the lack of player in some positions, notably number 8 and wing, while a plethora of options at blindside and tighthead prop.
What's notable is that there are four tighthead props involved, and that one of them isn't highly rated youngster Tadhg Furlong. I've also decided I am not going to criticise those named in this post, no matter how much I want to.
Ulster losers
The next major talking point revolves around an in form outsider, and an out of form, slightly injured formerly favoured player. I think it's very notable that Ian Keatley has been chosen ahead of Paddy Jackson, one because not many saw it coming, but mostly because the influence of Les Kiss on the Ulster set up would have expected to bring in more Ulster faces. Instead, players like Jackson, Cave, Wilson, McCloskey and Declan Fitzpatrick miss out. Fitzpatrick may be permanently injured, but he was the one time hope of Irish tightheads, and now there are at least 4 options probably ahead of him.
Lucky Thirteen
It's also intriguing to note that the first real squad where a successor to Brian O'Driscoll can be found features a grand total of 0 natural outside centres. Of the players in the squad who have played professional rugby at 13, three are fullbacks - Robbie Henshaw, Jared Payne and Darragh Leader, two are wingers - Tommy Bowe and Craig Gilroy, one is an outhalf - Ian Madigan, and two inside centres - Gordon D'Arcy and Stuart Olding.
Despite this curveball, the announcement of two other fullbacks in the squad, while only three wingers, suggest that Payne and Henshaw are the de facto 13s, Leader is a back 3 cover and the wingers stay out wide.
A final congratulatory note to Darragh Leader's inclusion. He may not get any gametime, but it's clear that his involvement will only benefit him in the long run. A quiet guy that needs to come out of his shell more, will only develop with this confidence boost, and given the improvements Henshaw and Marmion have made to their games since being involved with Schmidt, I've no doubt that Leader will make similar strides which can only benefit the player, his province and maybe Ireland in the future.
Thursday 16 October 2014
Irish Eye On The World Cup Squad 2: PRE European Cups
A lot has happened since the last Irish Eye, so it's best to have a look at the top 31 in pole position to make Joe's squad for next year's squad and the closest contenders.
Injuries and form have changed a bit, and after these two weeks of European action, I expect more from Leinster, Munster and Ulster to put their hand up.
Major Changes:
I believe that James Cronin's form is better than Dave Kilcoyne. Their battle for the final loosehead spot will be fascinating, and one to watch. There is a real danger that the winner of this duel will be the only Munster front row representative in the squad.
Martin Moore's injury is putting him in doubt, but the biggest beneficiary of this is Tadhg Furlong, who may usurp Moore's position in Leinster, and find himself second choice Irish tighthead. This may or may not be dependent on Declan Fitzpatrick's permanent injuries.
Kieran Marmion's form has to place him in front of Isaac Boss, who should be under threat from Luke McGrath both at Leinster and in Ireland, but Matt O'Connor doesn't like good young players.
I've moved Ian Madigan from a 10 candidate to a 12 candidate, and put him on the short plane to England/Wales. Stuart McCloskey is putting pressure on Luke Marshall and Stuart Olding, and whoever gets the most gametime there will be a frontrunner, but it's much to early to see who that could be. With Madigan and D'Arcy however, it'll be a tight battle.
Fergus McFadden's injury coupled with Simon Zebo's form have swapped those two, although I expect that will only be temporary.
Jared Payne has been simultaneously keeping Darren Cave out of the Ulster team, and proving to Irish rugby that his best position is full back without a shadow of a doubt. If he gets time there, he could/should put Rob Kearney's first team place under threat, but Joe's a loyal guy.
Injuries to Andrew Trimble at the worst time benefit Craig Gilroy immensely. He'll be looking to leapfrog the inactive Dave Kearney when given his chance in the next two weeks.
Injuries and form have changed a bit, and after these two weeks of European action, I expect more from Leinster, Munster and Ulster to put their hand up.
| 1st Choice | 2nd Choice | 3rd Choice | 4th Choice | 5th Choice | 6th Choice | 7th Choice | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cian Healy | Jack McGrath | James Cronin | Dave Kilcoyne | Callum Black | Denis Buckley | |
| 2 | Rory Best | Sean Cronin | Richardt Strauss | Damien Varley | Rob Herring | Mike Sherry | Duncan Casey |
| 3 | Mike Ross | Martin Moore | Declan Fitzpatrick | Tadhg Furlong | Nathan White | Rodney Ah You | Stephen Archer |
| 4 | Devin Toner | Iain Henderson | Donnacha Ryan | Dave Foley | Donncha O'Callaghan | ||
| 5 | Paul O'Connell | Dan Tuohy | Mike McCarthy | Mick Kearney | |||
| 6 | Peter O'Mahony | Rhys Ruddock | Robbie Diack | Kevin McLaughlin | |||
| 7 | Sean O'Brien | Chris Henry | Jordi Murphy | Tommy O'Donnell | Dominic Ryan | Sean Dougall | |
| 8 | Jamie Heaslip | Robin Copeland | Roger Wilson | Jack Conan | |||
| 9 | Conor Murray | Eoin Reddan | Kieran Marmion | Isaac Boss | Luke McGrath | Paul Marshall | |
| 10 | Jonathan Sexton | Paddy Jackson | Ian Keatley | JJ Hanrahan | |||
| 11 | Andrew Trimble | Simon Zebo | Dave Kearney | Luke Fitzgerald | |||
| 12 | Gordon D'Arcy | Ian Madigan | Luke Marshall | Stuart McCloskey | Stuart Olding | Noel Reid | |
| 13 | Robbie Henshaw | Jared Payne | Darren Cave | ||||
| 14 | Tommy Bowe | Fergus McFadden | Craig Gilroy | Keith Earls | |||
| 15 | Rob Kearney | Felix Jones |
Major Changes:
I believe that James Cronin's form is better than Dave Kilcoyne. Their battle for the final loosehead spot will be fascinating, and one to watch. There is a real danger that the winner of this duel will be the only Munster front row representative in the squad.
Martin Moore's injury is putting him in doubt, but the biggest beneficiary of this is Tadhg Furlong, who may usurp Moore's position in Leinster, and find himself second choice Irish tighthead. This may or may not be dependent on Declan Fitzpatrick's permanent injuries.
Kieran Marmion's form has to place him in front of Isaac Boss, who should be under threat from Luke McGrath both at Leinster and in Ireland, but Matt O'Connor doesn't like good young players.
I've moved Ian Madigan from a 10 candidate to a 12 candidate, and put him on the short plane to England/Wales. Stuart McCloskey is putting pressure on Luke Marshall and Stuart Olding, and whoever gets the most gametime there will be a frontrunner, but it's much to early to see who that could be. With Madigan and D'Arcy however, it'll be a tight battle.
Fergus McFadden's injury coupled with Simon Zebo's form have swapped those two, although I expect that will only be temporary.
Jared Payne has been simultaneously keeping Darren Cave out of the Ulster team, and proving to Irish rugby that his best position is full back without a shadow of a doubt. If he gets time there, he could/should put Rob Kearney's first team place under threat, but Joe's a loyal guy.
Injuries to Andrew Trimble at the worst time benefit Craig Gilroy immensely. He'll be looking to leapfrog the inactive Dave Kearney when given his chance in the next two weeks.
Wednesday 15 October 2014
I was saying Boo Urns
Never one to be left out of the loop, I must rush to join the chorus of Irish disapprovers in previewing the European rugby competition, that the English are already championing up to an extortionate amount. But, this isn't your typical preview, rather a couple of points that no one seems to be mentioning in their exulted praise of debt-ridden sport.
First, each English written preview starts off with phrases like "after all of the chaos and politics is better off". Is it unreasonable to ask how in the world you can possibly know that already? Unless my life has distracted me sufficiently to miss an entire season of this brand new competition, nothing has happened yet.
This claim is predicated on the fact that the groups are stronger than ever before. Nonsense. Let's take a look at Leinster's pools from the last few years.
2013/14: Leinster, Northampton, Castres, Ospreys
2012/13: Clermont, Leinster, Exeter, Scarlets
2011/12: Leinster, Glasgow, Bath, Montpeiller.
Further detail in that reveals in 2013/14, Leinster faced the Top 14 champions in Castres and one of the top 2 favourites (I'll come back to this) in Northampton? who went on to win the Premiership.
In 2012/13, Leinster were up against the best team from that era in Europe in Clermont, while the previous year, Glasgow were beginning their upward rise in the Pro 12, as were Montpeiller.
Compare that to this year, where Harlequins growth has stalled after some encouraging performances, Wasps are being uprooted and their main home resilence is being taken away from them, while Castres have started the Top 14 with 6 losses in their first 9, while conceding and average of 28.3 points per game, and only scoring 20.8.
But no, you're right the competition is much harder. It's not like before in those "easy" pools when Clermont and Leinster were together where both teams knew that relying on qualifying as a runner up was futile. Back in my day, European Rugby only allowed 2 of the 6 runners up to qualify for the quarter finals. That's 33% for those of us who prefer percentages. Let's compare that to this new fangled system of allowing 3 of these "elite" runners up into the quarters. Which for those who can do percentages looks a lot like 60%.
So this myth that it's harder to qualify for the quarters in this new fancy way of doing things actually seems to be easier. Because, I don't know about you, but as a team looking out for my own interests, I'd much rather have the cushion of knowing that second place gives me nearly double the change of qualifying.
This now means, according to other previews, that all games in all pools matter. What these goldfish forget is, none of that has changed. What made the Heineken Cup so magical was that every weekend counted. Any loss was a hammer blow to all sides, but now two or more losses could get a third second place team into the quarter finals. That's the price of being "elite".
I fail to see how pointing to the expansion of Super Rugby helps the argument that things are now better in Europe, especially when one preview mentioned that it took Western Force a whole 9 years to be competitive since they were introduced. Let's take a moment and reflect on this. Imagine how long it would have taken the Force to be competitive if they hadn't been playing against quality opposition week in and week out?
Take the European example of Treviso, who after 3 years in the Pro 12 started making progress by finishing a respectable 7th, before their squad was plundered by the English and French. How can any team continue to keep players like Botes, De Marchi, Cittadini, McLean, Williams, Vosawau, Loamanu, Ghiraldini, Barbieri, Rizzo, Di Bernardo, Berquist and Semenzato without the lure of top rugby?
At their height, they conceded 27.8 points per game and scored 17.8 points per game in Europe. Not too dissimilar from Castres record now is it? Should the English cast those lot out too?
Club rugby has been dealt a development blow in Europe, and it's time the English stopped pretending like things are fine and dandy.
First, each English written preview starts off with phrases like "after all of the chaos and politics is better off". Is it unreasonable to ask how in the world you can possibly know that already? Unless my life has distracted me sufficiently to miss an entire season of this brand new competition, nothing has happened yet.
This claim is predicated on the fact that the groups are stronger than ever before. Nonsense. Let's take a look at Leinster's pools from the last few years.
2013/14: Leinster, Northampton, Castres, Ospreys
2012/13: Clermont, Leinster, Exeter, Scarlets
2011/12: Leinster, Glasgow, Bath, Montpeiller.
Further detail in that reveals in 2013/14, Leinster faced the Top 14 champions in Castres and one of the top 2 favourites (I'll come back to this) in Northampton? who went on to win the Premiership.
In 2012/13, Leinster were up against the best team from that era in Europe in Clermont, while the previous year, Glasgow were beginning their upward rise in the Pro 12, as were Montpeiller.
Compare that to this year, where Harlequins growth has stalled after some encouraging performances, Wasps are being uprooted and their main home resilence is being taken away from them, while Castres have started the Top 14 with 6 losses in their first 9, while conceding and average of 28.3 points per game, and only scoring 20.8.
But no, you're right the competition is much harder. It's not like before in those "easy" pools when Clermont and Leinster were together where both teams knew that relying on qualifying as a runner up was futile. Back in my day, European Rugby only allowed 2 of the 6 runners up to qualify for the quarter finals. That's 33% for those of us who prefer percentages. Let's compare that to this new fangled system of allowing 3 of these "elite" runners up into the quarters. Which for those who can do percentages looks a lot like 60%.
So this myth that it's harder to qualify for the quarters in this new fancy way of doing things actually seems to be easier. Because, I don't know about you, but as a team looking out for my own interests, I'd much rather have the cushion of knowing that second place gives me nearly double the change of qualifying.
This now means, according to other previews, that all games in all pools matter. What these goldfish forget is, none of that has changed. What made the Heineken Cup so magical was that every weekend counted. Any loss was a hammer blow to all sides, but now two or more losses could get a third second place team into the quarter finals. That's the price of being "elite".
I fail to see how pointing to the expansion of Super Rugby helps the argument that things are now better in Europe, especially when one preview mentioned that it took Western Force a whole 9 years to be competitive since they were introduced. Let's take a moment and reflect on this. Imagine how long it would have taken the Force to be competitive if they hadn't been playing against quality opposition week in and week out?
Take the European example of Treviso, who after 3 years in the Pro 12 started making progress by finishing a respectable 7th, before their squad was plundered by the English and French. How can any team continue to keep players like Botes, De Marchi, Cittadini, McLean, Williams, Vosawau, Loamanu, Ghiraldini, Barbieri, Rizzo, Di Bernardo, Berquist and Semenzato without the lure of top rugby?
At their height, they conceded 27.8 points per game and scored 17.8 points per game in Europe. Not too dissimilar from Castres record now is it? Should the English cast those lot out too?
Club rugby has been dealt a development blow in Europe, and it's time the English stopped pretending like things are fine and dandy.
Saturday 6 September 2014
Irish Eye on the World Cup Squad 1
Starting "pre" season, I will be attemtping to have a look at the probable world cup fight for places in each position after "every week"
For this week, here is a look at how Joe viewed his squad based on the summer tours and the 6 Nations roughly. Bold is my attempted guess on cutting it down to the 30 players he can take to England in 2015 were it tomorrow. While italics are not involved.
Now, this isn't what I'd choose as my 30, but what it appears to me how Joe is thinking. It also highlights the tough choices ahead, as most squads announced contain 35 players, while the World Cup squad only allows 30. This means a tough pick between a 4th centre or a 5th back three player, while also reducing the number of props and backrowers in the squad. It's also likely that there will only be two outhalves involved aswell.
I've also forgotten some players, mostly injured, so all corrections, comments and tips welcome.
For this week, here is a look at how Joe viewed his squad based on the summer tours and the 6 Nations roughly. Bold is my attempted guess on cutting it down to the 30 players he can take to England in 2015 were it tomorrow. While italics are not involved.
Now, this isn't what I'd choose as my 30, but what it appears to me how Joe is thinking. It also highlights the tough choices ahead, as most squads announced contain 35 players, while the World Cup squad only allows 30. This means a tough pick between a 4th centre or a 5th back three player, while also reducing the number of props and backrowers in the squad. It's also likely that there will only be two outhalves involved aswell.
| 1st Choice | 2nd Choice | 3rd Choice | 4th Choice | 5th Choice | 6th Choice | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cian Healy | Jack McGrath | Dave Kilcoyne | James Cronin | ||
| 2 | Rory Best | Sean Cronin | Richardt Strauss | Damien Varley | Rob Herring | Mike Sherry |
| 3 | Mike Ross | Martin Moore | Declan Fitzpatrick | Rodney Ah You | Stephen Archer | |
| 4 | Devin Toner | Iain Henderson | Donnacha Ryan | Donncha O'Callaghan | ||
| 5 | Paul O'Connell | Dan Tuohy | Mike McCarthy | |||
| 6 | Peter O'Mahony | Rhys Ruddock | Robbie Diack | Kevin McLaughlin | ||
| 7 | Sean O'Brien | Chris Henry | Jordi Murphy | Tommy O'Donnell | ||
| 8 | Jamie Heaslip | Robin Copeland | Roger Wilson | |||
| 9 | Conor Murray | Eoin Reddan | Isaac Boss | Kieran Marmion | Paul Marshall | |
| 10 | Jonathan Sexton | Paddy Jackson | Ian Madigan | Ian Keatley | ||
| 11 | Andrew Trimble | Fergus McFadden | Simon Zebo | |||
| 12 | Gordon D'Arcy | Luke Marshall | Stuart Olding | Noel Reid | ||
| 13 | Darren Cave | Robbie Henshaw | Jared Payne | |||
| 14 | Tommy Bowe | Dave Kearney | Keith Earls | Craig Gilroy | ||
| 15 | Rob Kearney | Felix Jones |
I've also forgotten some players, mostly injured, so all corrections, comments and tips welcome.
Friday 5 September 2014
Youngsters To Watch In the Interprovincial Under 20 Championship
The age grade interprovincial games start this weekend, and they are the first time we get to see the stars of the future show what they can do. This year, the vast majority of those who played U20 last year, while still being underage, are ineligible for the tournament due to new rules. Some players, like Harrison Brewer, have been given an exemption. This means that more players are given a chance to stake their claim for further honours with Ireland U20, and here are four candidates who will look to lead their provinces to glory.
Munster - Stephen Fitzgerald
Fresh out of Ard Scoil Ris, this 18 year old fullback has already featured in the senior set up, and was involved in the pre season friendly against Gloucester. That's really all you need to know about this talented youngster, who is one of the brightest backline prospects from Munster since Keith Earls. He would be a shoo in for Irish honours if not for the surplus of talent in the back three at this age already - Jack Power, Jacob Stockdale, Billy Dardis and Ciaran Gaffney. Needless to say, while Ireland are well stocked, Fitzgerald can at least go on to have a highly successful career for the southern province.
He's the focal point of an exciting backline featuring Irish U19 international and sprinter Greg O'Shea, U20 scrumhalf Jack Culln, while Gearoid Lyons and Tomas Quinlan are two very handy distributors.
Connacht - Cian Romaine
Ireland U19 international and Connacht academy player Cian Romaine stands out in a highly talented Connacht U20 team. The thing about the tall second row that stands out the most is his impressive motor. Romaine has a huge work rate, and will be noticed on the pitch doing several positive actions time and time again. He hounds ball carriers in defense, and carries effectively and supports well in attack. The future is extremely bright for this Buccaneers clubman
Leinster - Nick Timoney
The former Blackrock college no.8 is another outstanding backrower coming through Leinster's ranks. Extremely highly rated coming out of school, Timoney can play across the backrow, but is most suited to 8. He will go strength to strength, and will lead a Leinster U20 team shorn of their JWC experience.
Ulster - Jacob Stockdale
When the first you hear of Stockdale is the hat trick of tries he scored for Ireland U18 last year, you take notice. From that moment on, Stockdale was a try scoring machine, whether from outside centre, wing or his preferred position of fullback. This kid is a talent, is only U19, and as a first year Ulster academy player, was already involved in Ulster senior pre season games.
He is the most exciting Ulster young backline star of recent years, and I'm including Craig Gilroy, Luke Marshall, Paddy Jackson and Stuart Olding in that.
Munster - Stephen Fitzgerald
Fresh out of Ard Scoil Ris, this 18 year old fullback has already featured in the senior set up, and was involved in the pre season friendly against Gloucester. That's really all you need to know about this talented youngster, who is one of the brightest backline prospects from Munster since Keith Earls. He would be a shoo in for Irish honours if not for the surplus of talent in the back three at this age already - Jack Power, Jacob Stockdale, Billy Dardis and Ciaran Gaffney. Needless to say, while Ireland are well stocked, Fitzgerald can at least go on to have a highly successful career for the southern province.
He's the focal point of an exciting backline featuring Irish U19 international and sprinter Greg O'Shea, U20 scrumhalf Jack Culln, while Gearoid Lyons and Tomas Quinlan are two very handy distributors.
Connacht - Cian Romaine
Ireland U19 international and Connacht academy player Cian Romaine stands out in a highly talented Connacht U20 team. The thing about the tall second row that stands out the most is his impressive motor. Romaine has a huge work rate, and will be noticed on the pitch doing several positive actions time and time again. He hounds ball carriers in defense, and carries effectively and supports well in attack. The future is extremely bright for this Buccaneers clubman
Leinster - Nick Timoney
The former Blackrock college no.8 is another outstanding backrower coming through Leinster's ranks. Extremely highly rated coming out of school, Timoney can play across the backrow, but is most suited to 8. He will go strength to strength, and will lead a Leinster U20 team shorn of their JWC experience.
Ulster - Jacob Stockdale
When the first you hear of Stockdale is the hat trick of tries he scored for Ireland U18 last year, you take notice. From that moment on, Stockdale was a try scoring machine, whether from outside centre, wing or his preferred position of fullback. This kid is a talent, is only U19, and as a first year Ulster academy player, was already involved in Ulster senior pre season games.
He is the most exciting Ulster young backline star of recent years, and I'm including Craig Gilroy, Luke Marshall, Paddy Jackson and Stuart Olding in that.
Irish Players to Watch in Pro 12
With a season left until the World Cup, this is the time for peripheral players to start making a case. Others may need a big season to guarantee future careers, while others have been threatening to break out for a while, and could use a big season to show that they can be the names the provinces build their teams around for years to come.
Leinster - Luke McGrath
We all expected McGrath to break out last season, and while I have my theories as to why he didn't, this year there is perhaps some pressure on him to succeed. Both Reddan and Boss are a year closer to retirement which helps, while his main young competitor has been given a loan deal to Connacht for the season.
While he has a safety net of having signed his first full professional contract last season, due to run out in 2016, there are a number of talented scrumhalves being churned out by Girvan Dempsey's academy and the Leinster schools; with Nick McCarthy and Charlie Rock showing some talented signs. All this means is that McGrath will have to have a year much like Noel Reid's last season to ensure that he can be the future Lion some have tipped him to be. And who knows, of all positions in the Irish camp, scrumhalf is one of the most shallow, and after Conor Murray made the World Cup squad in 2011 based on one full season, maybe this time McGrath has a chance.
Munster - Sean Dougall
It's quite hard to pick a player that Munster, Ireland and the player need to have a big season. Most of the players are either established already, or I don't believe have a huge amount of growth left in them. An ideal candidate would have been an inside centre, but I'm not convinced that 27 year old Ivan Dineen, or 23 year old Cian Bohane can push on, or will be given the chance to.
So instead, I think Sean Dougall (24), can keep growing. He pushed Tommy O'Donnell hard last year, and even started ahead of O'Donnell is several big games. Ireland can always use options at openside, and in Munster there are two very good options. Munster and Ireland could really use a big season from Dougall because either a) he beats O'Donnell for a spot, and starts to become a viable option for Ireland, or b) he pushes O'Donnell, causing him to grow into a viable option for Ireland.
Long story short, an in form Dougall should be good for Ireland, with a Munster openside pushing for inclusion in Joe's squads.
Ulster - Conor Joyce
Losing Stephen Ferris would cripple most sides, but Ulster managed to nearly pull a great season out of the bag. They do however need their other players to step up in his place though. With Iain Henderson almost certainly moving into the second row, and only Robbie Diack and Chris Henry with meaningful experience in the backrow, I'm backing last years Ireland under 20 blindside flanker Conor Joyce to make a big step up and will get some meaningful minutes.
Sean Reidy and Charlie Butterworth are two new signings with limited experience, but Joyce is one of the brightest prospects to come out of the Ulster academy, and could see himself in important matchday squads a lot this season.
Connacht - Caolan Blade
Blade is one of the most talented players in the Connacht academy right now. Highly rated among the Connacht staff, Blade made his first Pro12 appearance towards the end of the season last year after only one year in Nigel Carolan's academy.
Kieran Marmion has started 47 of 48 games for Connacht in the last two seasons, which means he will not be able to continue his remarkable run. The IRFU player welfare system will ensure Marmion does get a few rests this year too. With Frank Murphy and Paul O'Donohue gone from the squad, and despite John Cooney and Ian Porter's arrival, I'm backing Blade to show that not only will he be no.2 to Marmion, but if he works hard, he could be a threat to Marmion's monopoly on the Connacht no.9 jersey in the coming years.
Agree or disagree? Questions and comments always welcome. Did I miss anyone?
Leinster - Luke McGrath
We all expected McGrath to break out last season, and while I have my theories as to why he didn't, this year there is perhaps some pressure on him to succeed. Both Reddan and Boss are a year closer to retirement which helps, while his main young competitor has been given a loan deal to Connacht for the season.
While he has a safety net of having signed his first full professional contract last season, due to run out in 2016, there are a number of talented scrumhalves being churned out by Girvan Dempsey's academy and the Leinster schools; with Nick McCarthy and Charlie Rock showing some talented signs. All this means is that McGrath will have to have a year much like Noel Reid's last season to ensure that he can be the future Lion some have tipped him to be. And who knows, of all positions in the Irish camp, scrumhalf is one of the most shallow, and after Conor Murray made the World Cup squad in 2011 based on one full season, maybe this time McGrath has a chance.
Munster - Sean Dougall
It's quite hard to pick a player that Munster, Ireland and the player need to have a big season. Most of the players are either established already, or I don't believe have a huge amount of growth left in them. An ideal candidate would have been an inside centre, but I'm not convinced that 27 year old Ivan Dineen, or 23 year old Cian Bohane can push on, or will be given the chance to.
So instead, I think Sean Dougall (24), can keep growing. He pushed Tommy O'Donnell hard last year, and even started ahead of O'Donnell is several big games. Ireland can always use options at openside, and in Munster there are two very good options. Munster and Ireland could really use a big season from Dougall because either a) he beats O'Donnell for a spot, and starts to become a viable option for Ireland, or b) he pushes O'Donnell, causing him to grow into a viable option for Ireland.
Long story short, an in form Dougall should be good for Ireland, with a Munster openside pushing for inclusion in Joe's squads.
Ulster - Conor Joyce
Losing Stephen Ferris would cripple most sides, but Ulster managed to nearly pull a great season out of the bag. They do however need their other players to step up in his place though. With Iain Henderson almost certainly moving into the second row, and only Robbie Diack and Chris Henry with meaningful experience in the backrow, I'm backing last years Ireland under 20 blindside flanker Conor Joyce to make a big step up and will get some meaningful minutes.
Sean Reidy and Charlie Butterworth are two new signings with limited experience, but Joyce is one of the brightest prospects to come out of the Ulster academy, and could see himself in important matchday squads a lot this season.
Connacht - Caolan Blade
Blade is one of the most talented players in the Connacht academy right now. Highly rated among the Connacht staff, Blade made his first Pro12 appearance towards the end of the season last year after only one year in Nigel Carolan's academy.
Kieran Marmion has started 47 of 48 games for Connacht in the last two seasons, which means he will not be able to continue his remarkable run. The IRFU player welfare system will ensure Marmion does get a few rests this year too. With Frank Murphy and Paul O'Donohue gone from the squad, and despite John Cooney and Ian Porter's arrival, I'm backing Blade to show that not only will he be no.2 to Marmion, but if he works hard, he could be a threat to Marmion's monopoly on the Connacht no.9 jersey in the coming years.
Agree or disagree? Questions and comments always welcome. Did I miss anyone?
Tuesday 19 August 2014
Australia's NRC: Explained
This Thursday 21st of August, Australia's second attempt at launching a national third tier rugby championship. The NRC, the newest incarnation of the failed Australian Rugby Championship aims to be Australia's answer to New Zealand's ITM Cup and South Africa's Currie Cup; both of which are prestigious tournaments that are a breeding ground for young talent.
But the NRC is not just any tournament; the ARU in their infinite wisdom are desperate to both develop their playing depth to properly compete with their southern hemisphere rivals, and to have a profitable tournament. Several new rules will be trialled, as well as a requirement for all of Australia's Super Rugby players not involved in national set-ups to participate.
This article will include everything you need to know based on what teams are playing, what Super Rugby teams players are taken from, who appears the strongest team, the new rules, and whether this is a competition worth following.
One of the best things about the tournament is the desire to bring rugby to places that wouldn't be familiar with a high standard of player. This is why Brisbane City, NSW Country Eagles, Perth Spirit, and Queensland Country are taking their home games to multiple venues to get the largest catchment area and drive interest in the competition.
Queensland Country: Greg Holmes, Saia Fainga'a, Beau Robinson, Mike Harris, Anthony Fainga'a, Ben Lucas, JJ Tuilagi.
Greater Sydney Rams: Jed Holloway, Chris Alcock, Mark Swanepoel, Ben Volavola, Lalakai Foketi, Taqele Naiyaravoro.
North Harbour Rays: Matt Lucas
Sydney Stars: Paddy Ryan, Jeremy Tilse, Totu Latu, Pat McCutcheon, Tom Carter, Peter Betham, Angus Roberts
NSW Country Eagles: Max Lahiff, Josh Mann-Rea, Mitchell Chapman, Tala Gray, Stephen Hoiles, Ita Vaea, Brendan McKibbin, Matt Carraro, Ed Stubbs, Chris Tuatura-Morrison, Pat Dellit
Melbourne Rising: Cruz Ah Nau, Paul Alo-Emilie, Toby Smith, Pat Leafa, Tom Sexton, Luke Jones, Caderyn Neville, Sean MacMahon, Lopeti Timani, Ben Meehan, Nic Stirzaker, Jack Debreczeni, Mitch Inman, Tom English, Telusa Veainu, Jonah Placid
University Of Canberra Vikings: Scott Sio, JP Smith, Ruan Smith, Siliva Silva, Fotu Auelua, Jarrad Butler, Jordan Smiler, Christian Lealiifano, Henry Speight, Robbie Coleman, Jesse Mogg
Perth Spirit: Pek Cowan, T Faulkner, Ollie Hoskins, Heath Tessman, Sam Wykes, Matt Hodgson, Ben McCalman, Ian Prior, Zack Holmes, Kyle Godwin, Junior Rasolea, Marcel Braache, Luke Morahan, Dane Haylett-Petty
Taking out all of the internationals currently involved in Australia's Rugby Championship campaign; the strongest NRC teams appear to be the Canberra Vikings, Perth Spirit or Melbourne Rising given their lack of internationals, and the fact that their teams are similar to their Super Rugby equivalents and no other team have shared them like with the Reds splitting into Brisbane City and Queensland Country.
Although the players I'm most looking forward to seeing are Jake McIntyre, the Brisbane City outhalf, Jonah Placid, the Melbourne Rising fullback and Taqele Naiyaravoro the massive Sydney Rams winger. For those three in particular, this competition is worth following.
But the NRC is not just any tournament; the ARU in their infinite wisdom are desperate to both develop their playing depth to properly compete with their southern hemisphere rivals, and to have a profitable tournament. Several new rules will be trialled, as well as a requirement for all of Australia's Super Rugby players not involved in national set-ups to participate.
This article will include everything you need to know based on what teams are playing, what Super Rugby teams players are taken from, who appears the strongest team, the new rules, and whether this is a competition worth following.
The Basics
Australia's National Rugby Championship will last 11 weeks; with the nine participating teams playing each other once, before the top 4 play off to determine the inaugural champions. Each team will have 4 home games, 4 away games and a bye.
| Team | Area | Super Rugby Equivalent |
| Brisbane City | Brisbane, Queensland | Reds |
| Queensland Country | Queensland | Reds |
| Greater Sydney Rams | Sydney | Waratahs |
| North Harbour Rays | Sydney | Manly, Waratahs |
| Sydney Stars | Sydney | Waratahs |
| NSW Country Eagles | Lismore, NSW | Randwick, Waratahs, Brumbies |
| Melbourne Rising | Melbourne | Melbourne Rebels |
| University of Canberra Vikings | Canberra | ACT Brumbies |
| Perth Spirit | Perth | Western Force |
One of the best things about the tournament is the desire to bring rugby to places that wouldn't be familiar with a high standard of player. This is why Brisbane City, NSW Country Eagles, Perth Spirit, and Queensland Country are taking their home games to multiple venues to get the largest catchment area and drive interest in the competition.
Notable Players To Look Out For:
Brisbane City: James Hanson, James Horwill, David McDuling, Curtis Browning, Jake Schatz, Nick Frisby, Jake McIntyre, Samu Kerevi, Ben Tapuai, Lachie Turner, Chris Kuridrani.Queensland Country: Greg Holmes, Saia Fainga'a, Beau Robinson, Mike Harris, Anthony Fainga'a, Ben Lucas, JJ Tuilagi.
Greater Sydney Rams: Jed Holloway, Chris Alcock, Mark Swanepoel, Ben Volavola, Lalakai Foketi, Taqele Naiyaravoro.
North Harbour Rays: Matt Lucas
Sydney Stars: Paddy Ryan, Jeremy Tilse, Totu Latu, Pat McCutcheon, Tom Carter, Peter Betham, Angus Roberts
NSW Country Eagles: Max Lahiff, Josh Mann-Rea, Mitchell Chapman, Tala Gray, Stephen Hoiles, Ita Vaea, Brendan McKibbin, Matt Carraro, Ed Stubbs, Chris Tuatura-Morrison, Pat Dellit
Melbourne Rising: Cruz Ah Nau, Paul Alo-Emilie, Toby Smith, Pat Leafa, Tom Sexton, Luke Jones, Caderyn Neville, Sean MacMahon, Lopeti Timani, Ben Meehan, Nic Stirzaker, Jack Debreczeni, Mitch Inman, Tom English, Telusa Veainu, Jonah Placid
University Of Canberra Vikings: Scott Sio, JP Smith, Ruan Smith, Siliva Silva, Fotu Auelua, Jarrad Butler, Jordan Smiler, Christian Lealiifano, Henry Speight, Robbie Coleman, Jesse Mogg
Perth Spirit: Pek Cowan, T Faulkner, Ollie Hoskins, Heath Tessman, Sam Wykes, Matt Hodgson, Ben McCalman, Ian Prior, Zack Holmes, Kyle Godwin, Junior Rasolea, Marcel Braache, Luke Morahan, Dane Haylett-Petty
Taking out all of the internationals currently involved in Australia's Rugby Championship campaign; the strongest NRC teams appear to be the Canberra Vikings, Perth Spirit or Melbourne Rising given their lack of internationals, and the fact that their teams are similar to their Super Rugby equivalents and no other team have shared them like with the Reds splitting into Brisbane City and Queensland Country.
Although the players I'm most looking forward to seeing are Jake McIntyre, the Brisbane City outhalf, Jonah Placid, the Melbourne Rising fullback and Taqele Naiyaravoro the massive Sydney Rams winger. For those three in particular, this competition is worth following.
New Rules - Good Or Bizarre?
To me, the 14 experimental laws have a mix of inspired ideas, some intriguing concoctions and some downright idiotic variations.
The ones that get the most attention are the reduction in points for penalty kicks and drop goals, and the increase in the value of conversations. I'm fairly neutral on this, but overall I don't think it will work and will only encourage negative defensive tactics that will concede penalties instead of allowing attacking opportunities.
One of my favourite variations concerns the end of the game when the time is up. Previously when penalties are awarded after the 80 minutes expires, the attacking team didn't have the option of kicking to touch for a lineout because that would signal the end of play. No longer, attacking teams will be allowed this luxury and we could get more frantic and interesting close end games as a result.
Crooked lineouts will not be penalised if the defending team doesn't contest. This is within the bounds of acceptability (i.e. if the throw in is outside the outside shoulder then that's taking the piss.)
Kickers will have less time for conversations and penalties, while scrums will have to be set within 30 seconds of them being awarded. This is an interesting development, and needs to be trialled. It may not work, but at least we'll know after this.
There will be increased leniency on where quick penalties and free kicks are taken from, which can only increase the speed of the game.
Two rules I'm not fond concern mauls formed after the tackler holds the ball carrier up (which cannot be collapsed intentionally), and a quick throw can now be taken even if the ball has touched another person. Both seem wrong to me, especially the maul collapse. The reason collapsing a maul from a lineout is outlawed is due to safety, players are frequently hurt when this occurs, yet from the tackle, mauls have been collapsed intentionally from a tackle for about 4 years now with no record of any injury. The ball carrying team gains no advantage from this rule as they still will not be able to recover the ball once it's wrapped up, and it just makes the game slower because the maul can't collapse and play restarted faster. It's not really a rule that will make a huge amount of difference in Australia anyway, given the Australian way of playing rarely involves holding players up in the tackle.
Lastly, the rule I don't like at all -although reverting back to it will help people realise that having it in the first place is stupid and will end all nonsensical arguments - is the TMO rules. The NRC is reverting back to pre 2013, and stopping foul play and tries being reviewed unless it's in the try scoring area. While I agree that forward passes shouldn't be reviewed; allowing foul play to go unpunished mid-game offers the victimised team no method of benefiting from any punishment. The process needs to be reviewed to allow TMO's to review these instances while the game continues to minimise stoppages, not scrap the review completely.
Conclusion
In the previous incarnation of the competition back in 2007, the promotion focused on unheard of players that will one day end up becoming Wallabies. The players included were David Pocock, Kurtley Beale, Ben Daley, Matt Hodgson and the Fainga'a brothers. It's Australia's attempt to further increase depth so that there are more contenders to the Australian national squad. It's the next step after increasing the Australian representatives in Super Rugby from three to five teams. While that appeared to be a weakening of their resources, recent improvements are showing that Australian rugby is on the rise again, and having 5 teams playing at that high level will improve Australian rugby. NRC will add more players that otherwise wouldn't get a chance to play against Super Rugby calibre players to the depth.
Why is this interesting to Ireland? Perhaps you'll have to wait for the next blog post...
To be continued...
Thursday 14 August 2014
BHH #FantsBants Awards 2014
@BHHooker Well remembered! Lesson learned from last year though. Might need a dynamic, ball-handling hooker who can throw to get points!
— Simon Farrell (@SFarrell_5) February 11, 2014
The Second Twitter Super Rugby fantasy league went to new heights this year. Bants were flowing, with outrageous statements followed by crashing burns, while the nice guys snuck their way to the top. I wanted to hand out some metaphorical awards in appreciation of some great banter, and hope for more to come in following tournaments (aka The Rugby Championship 2014, watch this space).
The top 6 finishers (combined H2H/Table) will be invited into the Rugby Championship Head to Head league, while the standard table format will be open to all HERE.
The Cillian Hogan Choking a Lead Going Into The Final Award
Charlie Morgan - leading by ten points going into the final after a wonderful comeback to finally overtake last year's choker Cillian Hogan, Charlie ultimately ends up 52 points behind after Hogan finally manned up and got over the line. It wasn't so much a choke as it was, and this pains me to say, a win for PoseidonBelvedere.
The Drunk Uncle Award
Everyone has an uncle that make outrageous proclamations about their vast skills and experience in winning, only to majorly fall short in a giant crash and burn. There was really only one contender:
@BHHooker @Connachtman87 I like to think of myself as the Sir Clive Woodward of fantasy sports. Makes a lot of noise, but gets the job done.
— Alex Shaw (@alexshawsport) July 7, 2014
Another weekend, another W in fantasy rugby. I'm fantasy rugby's answer to Jose Mourinho. It's not pretty, but I get the job done.
— Alex Shaw (@alexshawsport) July 12, 2014
Better luck next time Alex.The Alofa Alofa award for the Best Team Name
Pure, Scrum Luck - Simon Farrell.
In a league full of not funny names, the only attempted rugby related pun has to win the award.
The Arsenal Award For Being Delighted With 4th Position
@BHHooker 4th in both if you don't count the experts...Only above me on points difference in the head-to-head, still three rounds to go...
— Alex Shaw (@alexshawsport) July 12, 2014
The Sneaks In To Contend While Others Are Fighting AwardUnlike other English participants in the league, one player was very quiet on twitter with negative boasting, and a desire to stay out of the limelight while he quietly went about his business. If the fantasy league stopped after the semi final, it would have been a genius ploy.
Take note, you in particular.
The WHY CANT YOU DO THAT EVERY WEEK Award
ConnachtMan Week 15 - 573 points
573 was by a distance the highest one week score anyone in the league managed. If the league was done in an F1 style points per week system then he might have done better, but no faulting him on this round, nice one ConnachtMan.
The BIG GAME Points Award
Arwel Jones with 525 points in the Playoffs was a massive score. So delighted Arwel was with it, as you can see:
Not a bad #FantsBants weekend...
— Arwel Jones (@agjones92) July 19, 2014
Keep your excitement down a bit Arwel.Although, as great as he was there, he did need to make up a few points because...
The Ready Made and Blasphemous "I Forgot To Do #FantsBants This Week" Award
How could somebody do that? Outrageous behaviour.
Forgot to do #fantsbants this weekend. But it's on @BHHooker!
— Arwel Jones (@agjones92) July 4, 2014
The Tweeter making Others Look Like a Twit AwardCredit where it's due, Cillian Hogan takes home both awards.
Just checked my #SuperRugby #FantsBants leagues. #IWin
— Cillian Hogan (@Cillian_Hogan) August 5, 2014
Tuesday 1 July 2014
JWC Team Of The Tournament 2013: Where Are They Now?
A year (and a bit) on from the wonderful Junior World Championship played in France, I thought it would be demonstrative to have a look at the progress of the best XV from that tournament and how their careers have gone on from that point. This should show how important the competition is, and which countries are the best at giving their youth a chance.
1. Ed Byrne (Ireland)
The Byrne twins had a superb tournament. Even though Ed wasn't necesarily first choice, he was by far the most impressive of Ireland's dominant front row in the tournament. This was the first tournament in memory where the Irish front row demolishing opponents in the scrum, and Byrne was a catalyst for lots of late game comebacks and improvements, especially in that unfortunate game against New Zealand.
The Byrne twins were highly touted prospects out of school, coming from the dominant period in Clongowes history, which has also featured the likes of Jordan Coughland and Conor Gilsenan.
Unfortunately, since the tournament, Byrne hasn't even appeared in the British & Irish Cup, with Cian Healy, Jack McGrath, Michael Bent and Jack O'Connell ahead of him in the pecking order. He will be looking for more gametime this season as he challenge Bent for the 3rd choice loosehead role, with O'Connell off to play for Bristol in the Championship. He will need to show signs of progression in his final season in the academy or his place in Leinster may be under threat.
2. Luke Cowan Dickie (England)
The JWC champions had one of their more impressive performers in the tournament. His performances on the rugby field excused his hair, which seemed to have gained a cult following. Highly thought of in England, big things were expected of the Exeter hooker after the tournament. He had played at loosehead prop the previous year, but his accurate darts, powerful scrummaging and wonderful loose play was a joy to behold.
Cowan-Dickie made a few appearances for the Chiefs this season, with several in the LV Cup, a couple in the Premiership and a Heineken Cup appearance. His potential is such that Lancaster deemed him worthy of inclusion into the extended England squad for their recent tour of New Zealand. Despite an injury ruling him out, the future looks bright for Cowan Dickie, and he's sure to push on next season.
3. Chris Taylor (Ireland)
Chris Taylor was the tighthead prop for Ireland that lead the scrum to demolishing all opponents. With the dearth of quality tighthead props in Ireland at the moment, many things were expected of Taylor on concluding the tournament.
Unfortunately, Ulster didn't offer Taylor a place in their academy following the tournament, although he did manage to feature once in the British and Irish Cup.While Ulster are losing John Afoa to Gloucester next season, and seem to be replacing him with quantity rather than quality, perhaps Taylor is the long term quality answer?
4. Irne Herbst (South Africa)
Herbst was one of South Africa more impressive forwards in the tournament. Another in the long line of South African locks, the powerfully built second row was impressive in his physicality and manage to score vital tries for his team.
Since the tournament, he's remained with the Blue Bulls U21 team, and has 8 caps in the Vodacom Cup. With the turnover in the Bulls at the moment, he will be targeting this year's Currie Cup to make his mark and push.
5. Patrick Tuipulotu (New Zealand)
For someone who nearly didn't make the Blues U17 team at the time, Tuipulotu was outstanding in the JWC, bringing his all action approach and high energy game all the way to the semi finals where New Zealand fell short.
Tuipulotu is the most well known name on this list so far. Owing due to a horrific injury suffered by Blues lock Calum Retallick on the eve of Super Rugby, Tuipulotu grabbed the last spot in the Blues squad and has gone from strength to strength, and continuing his impressive performances from the JWC. His form earned him a call up to the senior BNZ team, and he made his debut off the bench in the 2nd test against England in June. A force to be reckoned with for years to come.
6. Joseph Edwards
Edwards was part of a hugely impressive back row for New Zealand, with some huge hits, strong carries and brilliant support play. His experience from playing for Auckland in the ITM Cup the year before stood to him.
He went on to get more appearances for Auckland in the ITM Cup which was cut short by a dislocated shoulder. Despite this, Edwards was also named in the wider Blues training squad for 2014. Watch out for him to start showing his undoubted promise in this year's edition of the ITM Cup.
Mention for Steenkamp and Curtis Browning.
7. Ardie Savea
The IRB Junior Player of the Year nominee had a storming tournament, and showed the watching public why he's rated so highly. He was class in the loose, strong over the ball, and tackled furiously. His previous Super Rugby experience was evident, and Ardie always looked a class apart.
His 2013 got better after the JWC, and, along with a resurgent Victor Vito and Brad Shields, he was part of an all conquering Wellington Lions back row that nearly swept all before them before Canterbury shocked them in the final. His performances in that tournament also lead to him being called up as a non playing member of New Zealand's end of season tour, where Steve Hansen was able to get Savea used to BNZ's methods. No doubt he will be a feature of BNZ squads for years to come. In 2014, Jack Lam has been in outstanding form, and largely keeping Savea out of the Hurricanes starting line up. With Lam moving to Bristol next year, Savea will look to cement the Hurricanes 7 jumper for the next decade.
8. Jack Clifford
Clifford is another of the nominees for the IRB Junior Player of the Year after leading England to the JWC title. Clifford was the heartbeat of the English side. He never took a backwards step and was shown to be a proven leader.
Clifford is at one of the best clubs in England for young players, nurtured by Conor O'Shea, Clifford made 4 appearances with the senior side, and will no doubt be learning his apprenticeship under the experienced Nick Easter. With Easter the wrong side of 30, Clifford will be getting more opportunities in the coming season.
9. Stefan Ungerer
Ungerer beat of close competition for Rhodri Williams, whose service to Sam Davies was quick and sharp, but Ungerer played in the controlling scrumhalf mould for South Africa to a tee, and in a year when much was expected of Luke McGrath, Ungerer showed up the highly thought of Leinster prospect.
Ungerer played Vodacom Cup with the Natal Sharks in 2013, and was selected for the Shark's squad for the 2014 Super Rugby competition, making 4 sub appearances. With Charl McLeod moving to Grenoble, the opportunity for Ungerer to get more gametime will increase next season.
The challengers to Ungerer's position as the scrumhalf of the tournament were Rhodri Williams, who played 15 times for Scarlets in the Pro 12, with 6 Heineken Cup appearances, as well as two substitute appearances for the full Welsh side. Luke McGrath has gone on to make 8 sub appearances for Leinster in the Pro 12, as well as captaining the British and Irish cup side on occasion.
10. Sam Davies
The IRB Junior Player Of the Year had to make the team didn't he? His placekicking was flawless, his distribution was top drawer and his composure was exemplary.
Davies had a good season just gone with Ospreys, mainly finding himself in the 15 shirt. His 15 appearances in the Pro 12 show that despite the negatives surrounding the Welsh exodus, the talented youngsters are afforded a chance to play.
Other notable players were Henry Slade (18 Premiership appearances, 6 Heineken Cup appearances and an England game v the Barbarians) and Simon Hickey, who was underage in the tournament, went on to star for Auckland in the ITM Cup before establishing himself as the first choice number 10 for John Kirwan at the Blues making nine starts. Hickey captained the baby BNZs unsuccessfully in JWC 2014.
11. Seabelo Senatla
The Blitzbokke star was outstanding in this tournament. His pace, finishing and ability to ghost past defenders was beautiful to watch. His sevens experience shone out, and perhaps sent a message to other nations that this could be a valuable tool for youngsters progression.
Senatla was nominated for the South African 7s player of the year, and resigned to play 7s again for 2014.
Other talented wings that missed out include Jack Nowell, who in between his Chiefs appearances, started all 5 games for England in the 6 Nations and managed to find time to appear on Sky Sports as a pundit for JWC 2014, and Jordan Williams, who dazzled spectators in his 18 Pro 12 games, also appearing in the Heineken Cup in each game and for Wales. Fa'asiu Fuatai is another whose pace and finishing stood out, and his appearances for Otago in the ITM Cup 2013 certainly showed his ability.
12. Michael Collins
The lesser heralded of two centres in the New Zealand team, you wouldn't have known that Collins was the one without Super Rugby experience had you watched him play. Collins was outstanding in the New Zealand midfield as both as 12 and a 13.
Collins went on to play the full season for Otago in the ITM Cup, and will be gearing up for another season in the ITM cup when it kicks off in August.
Sam Hill was the only challenger to Collins, with the Englishman a beacon of composure throughout the tournament. Like his Exeter Chiefs teammates before him, Hill has gone on to make 4 Heineken Cup appearances, and 15 Premiership appearances.
13. Tom Farrell
As mentioned in the original article last year, Farrell really got the nod by default, with no 13 standing out, and me going for the homer. Farrell was impressive in attack, and contributing at the breakdown, that was enough for me to get him in the team.
Farrell has struggled with injuries in recent years, but in his first year of Leinster academy he managed to get 2 B&I cup games. There is an opportunity ahead of him in the retirement of the current 13 in Leinster, but if this year's JWC is anything to go by; Farrell could have competition coming up behind him.
14. Rory Scholes
If Farrell was a potential homer decision, Scholes's inclusion in the list is anything but. It's rare for a team's best player to play on the wing, but Scholes made some vital try saving tackles while also scoring a few at the other end.
Last season, Scholes took advantage of Andrew Trimble's resurgent season with Ireland to get some Pro 12 gametime during the internationals. He's close to establishing himself in the second string back three with Michael Allen and Craig Gilroy, although Louis Ludik may have something to say about that.
Scholes's huge competition for this spot came in the form of Ashley Evans who was an U19 star who didn't deliver as well in this year's JWC, Santiago Cordero (5 senior caps for Argentina), and Cheslin Kolbe, who starred for the Blitzbokke before injury ruled him out of the start of the Stormer's Super Rugby campaign. His return to their team has coincided with a dramatic upturn in their fortunes.
15. Hallam Amos
Hallam Amos was, to me, the standout out player of the Welsh explosive back three. At the time I predicted that due to his age that he would be a contender for the player of the year trophy in 2014. his step was mesmeric, and was a huge contributor to the Welsh run to the final. His 8 previous Pro 12 games had stood to him in a great campaign.
The prediction that he would be a contender for the JWC player of the year in 2014 never came to pass. Luckily for Amos though, that was because of a call up to the senior Welsh trial match which meant he wasn't included in the Welsh JWC squad. Amos has been capped by the senior Wales team, and this comes after a season with 3 Amlin Challenge Cup caps and 16 Pro 12 appearances.
Like Amos, Anthony Watson has also stepped up from the JWC, starring for Bath in his 20 Aviva Premiership appearances and 6 Amlin Cup games. Injury has delayed his inevitable England debut.
1. Ed Byrne (Ireland)
The Byrne twins had a superb tournament. Even though Ed wasn't necesarily first choice, he was by far the most impressive of Ireland's dominant front row in the tournament. This was the first tournament in memory where the Irish front row demolishing opponents in the scrum, and Byrne was a catalyst for lots of late game comebacks and improvements, especially in that unfortunate game against New Zealand.
The Byrne twins were highly touted prospects out of school, coming from the dominant period in Clongowes history, which has also featured the likes of Jordan Coughland and Conor Gilsenan.
Unfortunately, since the tournament, Byrne hasn't even appeared in the British & Irish Cup, with Cian Healy, Jack McGrath, Michael Bent and Jack O'Connell ahead of him in the pecking order. He will be looking for more gametime this season as he challenge Bent for the 3rd choice loosehead role, with O'Connell off to play for Bristol in the Championship. He will need to show signs of progression in his final season in the academy or his place in Leinster may be under threat.
2. Luke Cowan Dickie (England)
The JWC champions had one of their more impressive performers in the tournament. His performances on the rugby field excused his hair, which seemed to have gained a cult following. Highly thought of in England, big things were expected of the Exeter hooker after the tournament. He had played at loosehead prop the previous year, but his accurate darts, powerful scrummaging and wonderful loose play was a joy to behold.
Cowan-Dickie made a few appearances for the Chiefs this season, with several in the LV Cup, a couple in the Premiership and a Heineken Cup appearance. His potential is such that Lancaster deemed him worthy of inclusion into the extended England squad for their recent tour of New Zealand. Despite an injury ruling him out, the future looks bright for Cowan Dickie, and he's sure to push on next season.
3. Chris Taylor (Ireland)
Chris Taylor was the tighthead prop for Ireland that lead the scrum to demolishing all opponents. With the dearth of quality tighthead props in Ireland at the moment, many things were expected of Taylor on concluding the tournament.
Unfortunately, Ulster didn't offer Taylor a place in their academy following the tournament, although he did manage to feature once in the British and Irish Cup.While Ulster are losing John Afoa to Gloucester next season, and seem to be replacing him with quantity rather than quality, perhaps Taylor is the long term quality answer?
4. Irne Herbst (South Africa)
Herbst was one of South Africa more impressive forwards in the tournament. Another in the long line of South African locks, the powerfully built second row was impressive in his physicality and manage to score vital tries for his team.
Since the tournament, he's remained with the Blue Bulls U21 team, and has 8 caps in the Vodacom Cup. With the turnover in the Bulls at the moment, he will be targeting this year's Currie Cup to make his mark and push.
5. Patrick Tuipulotu (New Zealand)
For someone who nearly didn't make the Blues U17 team at the time, Tuipulotu was outstanding in the JWC, bringing his all action approach and high energy game all the way to the semi finals where New Zealand fell short.
Tuipulotu is the most well known name on this list so far. Owing due to a horrific injury suffered by Blues lock Calum Retallick on the eve of Super Rugby, Tuipulotu grabbed the last spot in the Blues squad and has gone from strength to strength, and continuing his impressive performances from the JWC. His form earned him a call up to the senior BNZ team, and he made his debut off the bench in the 2nd test against England in June. A force to be reckoned with for years to come.
6. Joseph Edwards
Edwards was part of a hugely impressive back row for New Zealand, with some huge hits, strong carries and brilliant support play. His experience from playing for Auckland in the ITM Cup the year before stood to him.
He went on to get more appearances for Auckland in the ITM Cup which was cut short by a dislocated shoulder. Despite this, Edwards was also named in the wider Blues training squad for 2014. Watch out for him to start showing his undoubted promise in this year's edition of the ITM Cup.
Mention for Steenkamp and Curtis Browning.
7. Ardie Savea
The IRB Junior Player of the Year nominee had a storming tournament, and showed the watching public why he's rated so highly. He was class in the loose, strong over the ball, and tackled furiously. His previous Super Rugby experience was evident, and Ardie always looked a class apart.
His 2013 got better after the JWC, and, along with a resurgent Victor Vito and Brad Shields, he was part of an all conquering Wellington Lions back row that nearly swept all before them before Canterbury shocked them in the final. His performances in that tournament also lead to him being called up as a non playing member of New Zealand's end of season tour, where Steve Hansen was able to get Savea used to BNZ's methods. No doubt he will be a feature of BNZ squads for years to come. In 2014, Jack Lam has been in outstanding form, and largely keeping Savea out of the Hurricanes starting line up. With Lam moving to Bristol next year, Savea will look to cement the Hurricanes 7 jumper for the next decade.
8. Jack Clifford
Clifford is another of the nominees for the IRB Junior Player of the Year after leading England to the JWC title. Clifford was the heartbeat of the English side. He never took a backwards step and was shown to be a proven leader.
Clifford is at one of the best clubs in England for young players, nurtured by Conor O'Shea, Clifford made 4 appearances with the senior side, and will no doubt be learning his apprenticeship under the experienced Nick Easter. With Easter the wrong side of 30, Clifford will be getting more opportunities in the coming season.
9. Stefan Ungerer
Ungerer beat of close competition for Rhodri Williams, whose service to Sam Davies was quick and sharp, but Ungerer played in the controlling scrumhalf mould for South Africa to a tee, and in a year when much was expected of Luke McGrath, Ungerer showed up the highly thought of Leinster prospect.
Ungerer played Vodacom Cup with the Natal Sharks in 2013, and was selected for the Shark's squad for the 2014 Super Rugby competition, making 4 sub appearances. With Charl McLeod moving to Grenoble, the opportunity for Ungerer to get more gametime will increase next season.
The challengers to Ungerer's position as the scrumhalf of the tournament were Rhodri Williams, who played 15 times for Scarlets in the Pro 12, with 6 Heineken Cup appearances, as well as two substitute appearances for the full Welsh side. Luke McGrath has gone on to make 8 sub appearances for Leinster in the Pro 12, as well as captaining the British and Irish cup side on occasion.
10. Sam Davies
The IRB Junior Player Of the Year had to make the team didn't he? His placekicking was flawless, his distribution was top drawer and his composure was exemplary.
Davies had a good season just gone with Ospreys, mainly finding himself in the 15 shirt. His 15 appearances in the Pro 12 show that despite the negatives surrounding the Welsh exodus, the talented youngsters are afforded a chance to play.
Other notable players were Henry Slade (18 Premiership appearances, 6 Heineken Cup appearances and an England game v the Barbarians) and Simon Hickey, who was underage in the tournament, went on to star for Auckland in the ITM Cup before establishing himself as the first choice number 10 for John Kirwan at the Blues making nine starts. Hickey captained the baby BNZs unsuccessfully in JWC 2014.
11. Seabelo Senatla
The Blitzbokke star was outstanding in this tournament. His pace, finishing and ability to ghost past defenders was beautiful to watch. His sevens experience shone out, and perhaps sent a message to other nations that this could be a valuable tool for youngsters progression.
Senatla was nominated for the South African 7s player of the year, and resigned to play 7s again for 2014.
Other talented wings that missed out include Jack Nowell, who in between his Chiefs appearances, started all 5 games for England in the 6 Nations and managed to find time to appear on Sky Sports as a pundit for JWC 2014, and Jordan Williams, who dazzled spectators in his 18 Pro 12 games, also appearing in the Heineken Cup in each game and for Wales. Fa'asiu Fuatai is another whose pace and finishing stood out, and his appearances for Otago in the ITM Cup 2013 certainly showed his ability.
12. Michael Collins
The lesser heralded of two centres in the New Zealand team, you wouldn't have known that Collins was the one without Super Rugby experience had you watched him play. Collins was outstanding in the New Zealand midfield as both as 12 and a 13.
Collins went on to play the full season for Otago in the ITM Cup, and will be gearing up for another season in the ITM cup when it kicks off in August.
Sam Hill was the only challenger to Collins, with the Englishman a beacon of composure throughout the tournament. Like his Exeter Chiefs teammates before him, Hill has gone on to make 4 Heineken Cup appearances, and 15 Premiership appearances.
13. Tom Farrell
As mentioned in the original article last year, Farrell really got the nod by default, with no 13 standing out, and me going for the homer. Farrell was impressive in attack, and contributing at the breakdown, that was enough for me to get him in the team.
Farrell has struggled with injuries in recent years, but in his first year of Leinster academy he managed to get 2 B&I cup games. There is an opportunity ahead of him in the retirement of the current 13 in Leinster, but if this year's JWC is anything to go by; Farrell could have competition coming up behind him.
14. Rory Scholes
If Farrell was a potential homer decision, Scholes's inclusion in the list is anything but. It's rare for a team's best player to play on the wing, but Scholes made some vital try saving tackles while also scoring a few at the other end.
Last season, Scholes took advantage of Andrew Trimble's resurgent season with Ireland to get some Pro 12 gametime during the internationals. He's close to establishing himself in the second string back three with Michael Allen and Craig Gilroy, although Louis Ludik may have something to say about that.
Scholes's huge competition for this spot came in the form of Ashley Evans who was an U19 star who didn't deliver as well in this year's JWC, Santiago Cordero (5 senior caps for Argentina), and Cheslin Kolbe, who starred for the Blitzbokke before injury ruled him out of the start of the Stormer's Super Rugby campaign. His return to their team has coincided with a dramatic upturn in their fortunes.
15. Hallam Amos
Hallam Amos was, to me, the standout out player of the Welsh explosive back three. At the time I predicted that due to his age that he would be a contender for the player of the year trophy in 2014. his step was mesmeric, and was a huge contributor to the Welsh run to the final. His 8 previous Pro 12 games had stood to him in a great campaign.
The prediction that he would be a contender for the JWC player of the year in 2014 never came to pass. Luckily for Amos though, that was because of a call up to the senior Welsh trial match which meant he wasn't included in the Welsh JWC squad. Amos has been capped by the senior Wales team, and this comes after a season with 3 Amlin Challenge Cup caps and 16 Pro 12 appearances.
Like Amos, Anthony Watson has also stepped up from the JWC, starring for Bath in his 20 Aviva Premiership appearances and 6 Amlin Cup games. Injury has delayed his inevitable England debut.
Thursday 10 April 2014
FantsBants Review: Not so Sharpey
It's been a long time coming, but due to a downturn in the amount of work placed upon me it's back.
FANTSBANTS REVIEW
The season so far:
This season has had everything; from the Tahs finally living up to hype, to surprise packages from the Lions to misfits like the Crusaders and Stormers. Whatever people say about Northern hemisphere leagues, no league in rugby is as competitive or as entertaining than Super Rugby.
We've also had the clocks confusing even the "best" of us:
Week 3:
Blues 35-24 Crusaders
Not only did this game eradicate any doubts about getting up at 6.30, but it introduced the world to Patrick Tuipolutu and Tevita Li. Two fantastic youngsters with big futures ahead of them. In hindsight, the Crusaders haven't really recovered from this loss.
Waratahs 32-5 Reds
This game confirmed that the Tahs may just live up to the hype for once; while simultaneously giving the Reds a rude awakening.
@AlexShawSport's victory of Straight Razor XV catapulted him into the maybe contenders, while early leader Vic's Chiefs suffered their first loss.
Week 4:
Bulls 38-22 Blues
This game was significant just for the fact that it was Victor Matfield's first start on his return, and what a return. Matfield has been the difference between a good Bulls side and a very poor one. The intangible lift he has on those around him is incredible.
Western Force 32-7 Rebels
Despite my prediction, the Force destroyed the Rebels and haven't looked back since. I mean it was incredible.
@alexshawsport's ego grew with another win, while this round also featured the battle of the Hogans. Wins for Manawatu Spooners and Pure Scrum Luck keep them in touch.
Emma Massden Oakden and Jen McMillan had very impressive weeks.
Week 5:
Brumbies 28-23 Waratahs
The Brumbies check the Tahs progression, and the lacklustre performance from the Tahs certainly showed there remains some doubt as to their playoff credentials.
Lions 39-36 Blues
Another fantastic win for the Lions, with Warren Whiteley showing his ability.
Highlanders 29-31 Western Force
No one really expected the Force to back up their win the previous week, maybe a sign of things to come?
Northern Stereotype bring @alexshawsport crashing down to earth with a big win, while more wins for Straight Razor XV, Manawatu Spooners, Pure Scrum Luck and Poseidons Belvedere keep them interested.
A huge points total of 425 for Jen McMillan catapults her up the rankings.
Week 6:
Western Force 18-15 Chiefs
This game featured Kieran Longbottom diving his head into problems, the Western Force boys were d'ing like the boys in the trenches down in Gallipoli (maybe not that tough), the Chiefs were like that kid who fell out of the tree (they just weren't in it), and Nic Cummins is a busy as a one armed brick layer in Baghdad. Enough said really.
Lions 23-20 Reds
Not to be outdone, the Lions and officials spoiled the Reds with Quade Cooper approaching ominous form.
Another huge total from Flying Dice makes it two 400+ weeks in a row, while Charlie Morgan is quietly slipping into contention.
Week 7:
Rebels 32- 24 Brumbies
Finally some #REBdemption. After a fantastic start for the Rebels, the Force ambushed them in Perth and they lost their way. An 8 point victory over the Brumbies should set them right.
Crusaders 26-29 Hurricanes.
What a try from Leuia. And what a game. Further confirmation of the Crusaders demise to one of their bogey teams.
The pressure was getting to some people:
This was a ding dong battle if I ever saw one. Each side traded sharing the lead, before Hayward pops up with minutes to go to seal it for the Force and continue their remarkable run.
Cheetahs 41-41 Chiefs
For the second week in a row the Chiefs manage to avoid defeat after coming from behind to garner three match points.
While Pat McCabe did the business for the Brumbies which left some frustrated:
FantsBants:
So that leaves us with:
AND
FANTSBANTS REVIEW
The season so far:
This season has had everything; from the Tahs finally living up to hype, to surprise packages from the Lions to misfits like the Crusaders and Stormers. Whatever people say about Northern hemisphere leagues, no league in rugby is as competitive or as entertaining than Super Rugby.
We've also had the clocks confusing even the "best" of us:
@BHHooker contrasting clock changes in Northern/Southern Hemispheres threw me. Apologies, you're right. But JWC will still have an early KO.
— Alex Shaw (@alexshawsport) April 7, 2014
A look at the table shows that 13 of the 15 teams are bunched close together, with only the Stormers and the Cheetahs adrift at the foot of the table.
We have seen wonderful tries like this:
And brilliant interviews like this:
Highlights:
Week 3:
Blues 35-24 Crusaders
Not only did this game eradicate any doubts about getting up at 6.30, but it introduced the world to Patrick Tuipolutu and Tevita Li. Two fantastic youngsters with big futures ahead of them. In hindsight, the Crusaders haven't really recovered from this loss.
Waratahs 32-5 Reds
This game confirmed that the Tahs may just live up to the hype for once; while simultaneously giving the Reds a rude awakening.
@AlexShawSport's victory of Straight Razor XV catapulted him into the maybe contenders, while early leader Vic's Chiefs suffered their first loss.
Week 4:
Bulls 38-22 Blues
This game was significant just for the fact that it was Victor Matfield's first start on his return, and what a return. Matfield has been the difference between a good Bulls side and a very poor one. The intangible lift he has on those around him is incredible.
Western Force 32-7 Rebels
Despite my prediction, the Force destroyed the Rebels and haven't looked back since. I mean it was incredible.
@alexshawsport's ego grew with another win, while this round also featured the battle of the Hogans. Wins for Manawatu Spooners and Pure Scrum Luck keep them in touch.
Emma Massden Oakden and Jen McMillan had very impressive weeks.
Week 5:
Brumbies 28-23 Waratahs
The Brumbies check the Tahs progression, and the lacklustre performance from the Tahs certainly showed there remains some doubt as to their playoff credentials.
Lions 39-36 Blues
Another fantastic win for the Lions, with Warren Whiteley showing his ability.
Highlanders 29-31 Western Force
No one really expected the Force to back up their win the previous week, maybe a sign of things to come?
Northern Stereotype bring @alexshawsport crashing down to earth with a big win, while more wins for Straight Razor XV, Manawatu Spooners, Pure Scrum Luck and Poseidons Belvedere keep them interested.
A huge points total of 425 for Jen McMillan catapults her up the rankings.
Week 6:
Western Force 18-15 Chiefs
This game featured Kieran Longbottom diving his head into problems, the Western Force boys were d'ing like the boys in the trenches down in Gallipoli (maybe not that tough), the Chiefs were like that kid who fell out of the tree (they just weren't in it), and Nic Cummins is a busy as a one armed brick layer in Baghdad. Enough said really.
Lions 23-20 Reds
Not to be outdone, the Lions and officials spoiled the Reds with Quade Cooper approaching ominous form.
Another huge total from Flying Dice makes it two 400+ weeks in a row, while Charlie Morgan is quietly slipping into contention.
Week 7:
Rebels 32- 24 Brumbies
Finally some #REBdemption. After a fantastic start for the Rebels, the Force ambushed them in Perth and they lost their way. An 8 point victory over the Brumbies should set them right.
Crusaders 26-29 Hurricanes.
What a try from Leuia. And what a game. Further confirmation of the Crusaders demise to one of their bogey teams.
After 2weeks on holiday I'm back in #fantsbants mode. Wildcard played, deadwood cut @BHHooker better bring his A-game this week #TeamBringIt
— Simon Farrell (@SFarrell_5) March 27, 2014
Kudos to @BHHooker on his #fantsbants head-to-head victory over my boys this weekend, thought I had ya at one stage, not to be #CapDoffed
— Simon Farrell (@SFarrell_5) March 31, 2014
Week 8:The pressure was getting to some people:
Wish the Chiefs would announce their side so I can sort out my #fantsbants team.
— Arwel Jones (@agjones92) April 3, 2014
Reds 29-32 Western ForceThis was a ding dong battle if I ever saw one. Each side traded sharing the lead, before Hayward pops up with minutes to go to seal it for the Force and continue their remarkable run.
Cheetahs 41-41 Chiefs
For the second week in a row the Chiefs manage to avoid defeat after coming from behind to garner three match points.
While Pat McCabe did the business for the Brumbies which left some frustrated:
Leaving McCabe on the bench may have been a mistake... #fantsbants
— Arwel Jones (@agjones92) April 4, 2014
Highlight of the week was a huge 465 points from Steve Maher lifting him off the bottom of the table up 6 places. It can be done.FantsBants:
So that leaves us with:
AND
Sunday 23 March 2014
Building on Success
Irish rugby is in a fantastic place right now. Three provinces are in the Heineken Cup quarter finals, the same three are the top 3 in the Pro12 league, where the benefits of Heineken Cup rugby are helping Connacht push for 6th place and a place in next season's version. This doesn't even reflect the player production that each province are now producing, with a larger number of quality players coming through each academy than ever before. Ireland punches well above it's weight in the rugby world considering how small the sport in in an even smaller country.
And I haven't even mentioned the national team yet. The recent 6 Nations win was in my mind down to John Plumtree's work with the Irish forwards, Joe's tactical nous and a whole heap of luck. There's no question that Ireland are in good hands with Plumtree and Schmidt, but as Joe mentioned during the week, only picking 18 players through five games is a luxury he's unlikely to have again, which is why the strengthen of the Irish squad is one major point he talked about pre 6 Nations.
There are between 10 and 13 games between now and the World Cup, and given the need for momentum going into a championship, there isn't much time for experimentation. That's why this summer's tour is so important. There is a need to build on the momentum that the 6 Nations win brings, especially as Argentina are potential RWC quarterfinalist opposition for Ireland. That said, there are a number of opportunities to rest key players.
A number of senior players need to be rested to reach the World Cup in top form, some fringe players need opportunities, and some new leaders need to be given a chance to step up. Others should be rested to see what an alternative would be like in the event that the incumbent gets injured.
Without further ado, here is my 32 man Irish squad for the two test Argentina tour that accomplishes those goals while still being strong enough to win.
Fullback:
Rested: Rob Kearney.
Kearney is one of those virtually unchallenged for his jersey. That's why I think it could be prudent to rest him, and have a look at the next two challengers in line: Robbie Henshaw and Felix Jones.
Wingers:
No one is rested here. I count 8 options for Schmidt on the wings which means that the competition is fierce and being "rested" could result in a winger losing their place in the squad. The five I've gone for in this squad also give options for other positions in the backline.
In: Andrew Trimble, Dave Kearney, Tommy Bowe, Luke Fitzgerald, Simon Zebo.
Centres:
The start of life without O'Driscoll. I've already chosen Fitzgerald and Henshaw in the squad, and I think it might be best to save D'Arcy so he can last. I'm also going to give Luke Marshall another summer off due to his latest head knock, but he might be one to make the plane anyway. I don't think Stuart Olding will be back in time. This leaves Darren Cave and Fergus McFadden covering the centre positions.
Outhalf:
If Sexton doesn't get the summer off after the Top 14 campaign then something is wrong. This tour is tailor-made for resting him and giving the back up options some valuable gametime and international experience. Due to the lack of centres, I'm bringing three options, two of which can also play 12.
In: Paddy Jackson, Ian Madigan, JJ Hanrahan.
Scrumhalf:
Eoin Reddan and Isaac Boss are both over 33. Kieran Marmion has also been banging louder and louder on the door with each passing game. Conor Murray will travel, and I expect his game to rise again and take up a leadership role with Sexton, D'Arcy and Kearney missing from the touring squad. I suspect only one of Boss and Reddan will travel, if at all, as both know Schmidt's gameplan inside out and will be key in getting Marmion and Murray further up to speed with Joe's ways.
In: Murray, Marmion, Boss.
Loosehead:
Cian Healy is only 25. Remember that, and both he and Jack McGrath are better when the other is in the 23. Both travel and the fight is between James Cronin and Dave Kilcoyne for the third and last loosehead prop spot on the plane. No resting needed here.
In: Healy, McGrath, Kilcoyne.
Hooker:
While Healy is 25 and doesn't need a rest, the same cannot be said or Rory Best. Besides, In Richardt Strauss there is a viable alternative that will not reduce Ireland's competitiveness in the front row. Sean Cronin is also improving, and the last slot will go to Mike Sherry if he recovers from injury in time.
In: Strauss, Cronin, Sherry.
Tighthead:
I find myself calling for Mike Ross to be rested every summer, but this summer it is absolutely crucial. What a scrummaging education Martin Moore could get down in Argentina, while also giving gametime to Declan Fitzpatrick would be hugely beneficial to Ireland. Ross has been going non stop for nearly two years now, and despite his impressive 6 Nations, none of us what him to over do it.
In: Moore, Fitzpatrick.
Locks:
One thing that struck me when Ireland played Scotland was how little the loss of Paul O'Connell effected them. He is still an unbelievably inspirational figure, and walks into the Irish team, but Devin Toner and Dan Tuohy stood up well to the challenge. An overdue summer off would be good for the big man to recharge his batteries for the World Cup, while Toner and Tuohy will be joined by Donnacha Ryan and Iain Henderson as the locks for the tour. It's great to see such strength in depth that Mike McCarthy wouldn't even make that group.
Openside Flankers:
Sean O'Brien is injured, and I see absolutely no point in rushing him back for the tour, let him have a break and then give him the pre season to get himself right. This leaves Chris Henry continuing his great form in a green jersey, ably assisted by both Tommy O'Donnell and Jordi Murphy.
Blindside/ No.8.
Question: Who plays for Ireland at 8 when Jamie Heaslip is injured? Answer: It's never come up before. In the freakish event that it does happen in the next 18 months, it would be good for next in line to be given some gametime there. That's why I'd leave Heaslip at home, and give the 8 jersey and tour captaincy to Peter O'Mahony. Like Murray, O'Mahony would relish the leadership duties and has done well with the Munster captaincy this season. He's joined by Robin Copeland and Rhys Ruddock covering blindside and 8.
In: O'Mahony, Copeland, Ruddock
Squad in Full:
Felix Jones, Robbie Henshaw, Andrew Trimble, David Kearney, Simon Zebo, Tommy Bowe, Luke Fitzgerald. Fergus McFadden, Darren Cave, JJ Hanrahan, Ian Madigan, Paddy Jackson, Kieran Marmion, Isaac Boss, Conor Murray, Cian Healy, Jack McGrath, Dave Kilcoyne, Richardt Strauss, Sean Cronin, Mike Sherry, Martin Moore, Declan Fitzpatrick, Dan Tuohy, Devin Toner, Donnacha Ryan, Iain Henderson, Rhys Ruddock, Robin Copeland, Tommy O'Donnell, Chris Henry, Jordi Murphy, Peter O'Mahony (c)
And I haven't even mentioned the national team yet. The recent 6 Nations win was in my mind down to John Plumtree's work with the Irish forwards, Joe's tactical nous and a whole heap of luck. There's no question that Ireland are in good hands with Plumtree and Schmidt, but as Joe mentioned during the week, only picking 18 players through five games is a luxury he's unlikely to have again, which is why the strengthen of the Irish squad is one major point he talked about pre 6 Nations.
There are between 10 and 13 games between now and the World Cup, and given the need for momentum going into a championship, there isn't much time for experimentation. That's why this summer's tour is so important. There is a need to build on the momentum that the 6 Nations win brings, especially as Argentina are potential RWC quarterfinalist opposition for Ireland. That said, there are a number of opportunities to rest key players.
A number of senior players need to be rested to reach the World Cup in top form, some fringe players need opportunities, and some new leaders need to be given a chance to step up. Others should be rested to see what an alternative would be like in the event that the incumbent gets injured.
Without further ado, here is my 32 man Irish squad for the two test Argentina tour that accomplishes those goals while still being strong enough to win.
Fullback:
Rested: Rob Kearney.
Kearney is one of those virtually unchallenged for his jersey. That's why I think it could be prudent to rest him, and have a look at the next two challengers in line: Robbie Henshaw and Felix Jones.
Wingers:
No one is rested here. I count 8 options for Schmidt on the wings which means that the competition is fierce and being "rested" could result in a winger losing their place in the squad. The five I've gone for in this squad also give options for other positions in the backline.
In: Andrew Trimble, Dave Kearney, Tommy Bowe, Luke Fitzgerald, Simon Zebo.
Centres:
The start of life without O'Driscoll. I've already chosen Fitzgerald and Henshaw in the squad, and I think it might be best to save D'Arcy so he can last. I'm also going to give Luke Marshall another summer off due to his latest head knock, but he might be one to make the plane anyway. I don't think Stuart Olding will be back in time. This leaves Darren Cave and Fergus McFadden covering the centre positions.
Outhalf:
If Sexton doesn't get the summer off after the Top 14 campaign then something is wrong. This tour is tailor-made for resting him and giving the back up options some valuable gametime and international experience. Due to the lack of centres, I'm bringing three options, two of which can also play 12.
In: Paddy Jackson, Ian Madigan, JJ Hanrahan.
Scrumhalf:
Eoin Reddan and Isaac Boss are both over 33. Kieran Marmion has also been banging louder and louder on the door with each passing game. Conor Murray will travel, and I expect his game to rise again and take up a leadership role with Sexton, D'Arcy and Kearney missing from the touring squad. I suspect only one of Boss and Reddan will travel, if at all, as both know Schmidt's gameplan inside out and will be key in getting Marmion and Murray further up to speed with Joe's ways.
In: Murray, Marmion, Boss.
Loosehead:
Cian Healy is only 25. Remember that, and both he and Jack McGrath are better when the other is in the 23. Both travel and the fight is between James Cronin and Dave Kilcoyne for the third and last loosehead prop spot on the plane. No resting needed here.
In: Healy, McGrath, Kilcoyne.
Hooker:
While Healy is 25 and doesn't need a rest, the same cannot be said or Rory Best. Besides, In Richardt Strauss there is a viable alternative that will not reduce Ireland's competitiveness in the front row. Sean Cronin is also improving, and the last slot will go to Mike Sherry if he recovers from injury in time.
In: Strauss, Cronin, Sherry.
Tighthead:
I find myself calling for Mike Ross to be rested every summer, but this summer it is absolutely crucial. What a scrummaging education Martin Moore could get down in Argentina, while also giving gametime to Declan Fitzpatrick would be hugely beneficial to Ireland. Ross has been going non stop for nearly two years now, and despite his impressive 6 Nations, none of us what him to over do it.
In: Moore, Fitzpatrick.
Locks:
One thing that struck me when Ireland played Scotland was how little the loss of Paul O'Connell effected them. He is still an unbelievably inspirational figure, and walks into the Irish team, but Devin Toner and Dan Tuohy stood up well to the challenge. An overdue summer off would be good for the big man to recharge his batteries for the World Cup, while Toner and Tuohy will be joined by Donnacha Ryan and Iain Henderson as the locks for the tour. It's great to see such strength in depth that Mike McCarthy wouldn't even make that group.
Openside Flankers:
Sean O'Brien is injured, and I see absolutely no point in rushing him back for the tour, let him have a break and then give him the pre season to get himself right. This leaves Chris Henry continuing his great form in a green jersey, ably assisted by both Tommy O'Donnell and Jordi Murphy.
Blindside/ No.8.
Question: Who plays for Ireland at 8 when Jamie Heaslip is injured? Answer: It's never come up before. In the freakish event that it does happen in the next 18 months, it would be good for next in line to be given some gametime there. That's why I'd leave Heaslip at home, and give the 8 jersey and tour captaincy to Peter O'Mahony. Like Murray, O'Mahony would relish the leadership duties and has done well with the Munster captaincy this season. He's joined by Robin Copeland and Rhys Ruddock covering blindside and 8.
In: O'Mahony, Copeland, Ruddock
Squad in Full:
Felix Jones, Robbie Henshaw, Andrew Trimble, David Kearney, Simon Zebo, Tommy Bowe, Luke Fitzgerald. Fergus McFadden, Darren Cave, JJ Hanrahan, Ian Madigan, Paddy Jackson, Kieran Marmion, Isaac Boss, Conor Murray, Cian Healy, Jack McGrath, Dave Kilcoyne, Richardt Strauss, Sean Cronin, Mike Sherry, Martin Moore, Declan Fitzpatrick, Dan Tuohy, Devin Toner, Donnacha Ryan, Iain Henderson, Rhys Ruddock, Robin Copeland, Tommy O'Donnell, Chris Henry, Jordi Murphy, Peter O'Mahony (c)
Saturday 15 March 2014
How do you explain Brian O'Driscoll?
One of my American friends is getting into rugby, and given the timing I thought, how can you explain Brian O'Driscoll to someone unfamiliar to rugby? It occurs to me that current Irish school children may not even be aware of the impact that this one man has had on this beautiful game. O'Driscoll was the first Irish rugby superstar, helped by the advent of professionalism, and through his career, the landscape of rugby in Ireland has skyrocketed. Irish rugby was in a bad place in the 1990's, results were poor and the level of interest was confined to televised 6 Nations games, but three things changed all that. Professionalism was introduced in 1995, coupled with the Heineken Cup, allowing the best club and provincial teams to play each other more often, and the start of Brian O'Driscoll's career.
The Prodigy Years
Despite being the reserve scrumhalf in the all conquering Blackrock college team of 1996, O'Driscoll was brought into the Irish set up quickly, and at the age of 19, made his debut for Ireland before he'd featured for his home province. This is an extremely rare occurrence, almost unheard of actually, with only Michael Bent achieving something similar in bizarre circumstances in 2012. Unlike Bent, O'Driscoll's class was apparent from the start, with teammates saying "We all knew there was something special about the guy and he was going to kick on. We all knew he had the X-Factor as they say now" from an early age.
O'Driscoll though, took it in his stride and in 2000 in Paris, he announced himself to Europe. Ireland hadn't won a rugby game in France in 28 years, and this French team had been to the World Cup semi final a year previously. Not much was expected of Ireland, but for those who don't already know what happened, I'll let the video tell the story.
O'Driscoll was about to lead a crop of talented youngsters, the likes of which Irish rugby had never seen before, through the golden generation. The wider world, and the southern hemisphere were announced to his attacking brilliance on the 2001 Lions tour to Australia.
Team Player
What makes Brian O'Driscoll different to all other outstanding players in any sport is his determination. His defensive play is the strength of his game, and his intelligence and knowledge of the game keep him ahead of everyone in attack. When someone as colossal as Paul O'Connell says about O'Driscoll, that he'd be the first person he'd want in the trenches beside him, you know it means something. O'Driscoll is never one to shirk a challenge, and always put his body on the line for Leinster and Ireland. He lead that generation up and made them believe that no longer were Ireland there just to make up numbers, but that they were good enough to win silverware.
It may have taken a long time, but in 2004, Ireland won their first Triple Crown in 19 years. That wasn't enough for O'Driscoll, as this was achieved again in 2006, and a third time in 2007. In 2007 though, there was a feeling of regret, because none of these Triple Crowns brought with it a 6 Nations title. But this was to come later. The Irish people were slowing being brought into the culture of rugby.
Genius
It's amazing to think that he is as good as he is, even though his eyesight is as bad as it is. Because his vision to see things that others don't is out of this world. Perhaps that would explain why some of these pieces of brilliance have happened.
Trophies
By 2009, the whole country was on the edge of their seats. Playing Wales in the deciding game of the 6 Nations had grown men crying, and non sporty women screaming. BOD was at the peak of his powers. 4 tries in the tournament; a combination of brilliant attacking running lines, defensive awareness and digging in the trenches, O'Driscoll inspired Ireland to the 6 Nations title and their first Grand Slam for 62 years.
A first Heineken Cup followed that year, and awards reigned down on Ireland's favourite son. The IRB award for player of the decade followed, giving you a hint at how highly he was regarded in the rugby world.
Still Got It
Despite claims that he's "past it" since 2009, O'Driscoll continued winning trophies, with two more Heineken Cups to follow in 2011 and 2012, while still producing the same magic that lit up our screens more than a decade ago. It takes a special kind of player to maintain the level of consistency required to reach 100 caps, and last weekend, Brian O'Driscoll broke the world record for the number of international rugby matches played in, at 140. This Saturday v France, will be his 141st and final appearance on the international stage.
Brian O'Driscoll: Finishing his career with an Irish record 46 tries and a world record 141 appearances.
The epitome of a Lion
It's a huge achievement to become a British and Irish Lion. To be considered one of the best in England, Scotland, Ireland and Wales is one of the top honours for a rugby player from those countries. A bigger achievement to do it twice. O'Driscoll is one of a very selective few who went on four tours - 2001, 2005, 2009 and 2013. Not only that, but he was selected as captain on the ill fated tour to New Zealand in 2005.
In each tour, you can get a glimpse of the character and talent of O'Driscoll. You've seen the wonderous try against Australia in 2001, but in 2009 he showed his toughness with a huge hit on the massive Danie Roussouw (below).
Add to that, the reaction of the public in 2005, when Tana Umaga and Kevin Mealamu spear tackled him in the first minute of the first test, breaking his collarbone tells you a lot about how he is viewed in the public. Perhaps more enlightening was the reaction to seeing him dropped from the deciding test in 2013.
Public Perception
Despite a few dodgy haircuts throughout the years, O'Driscoll is firmly held in a positive light throughout the world. His approachability, and humour paint him as a likable guy even without the strings of fame that come with dragging Irish rugby out of the doldrums.
Not only that, but his charity work sets him apart as a stand up guy, and when children like this say nice things about you then...
I guess there is nothing more to say than: Thank you Brian
The Prodigy Years
Despite being the reserve scrumhalf in the all conquering Blackrock college team of 1996, O'Driscoll was brought into the Irish set up quickly, and at the age of 19, made his debut for Ireland before he'd featured for his home province. This is an extremely rare occurrence, almost unheard of actually, with only Michael Bent achieving something similar in bizarre circumstances in 2012. Unlike Bent, O'Driscoll's class was apparent from the start, with teammates saying "We all knew there was something special about the guy and he was going to kick on. We all knew he had the X-Factor as they say now" from an early age.
O'Driscoll though, took it in his stride and in 2000 in Paris, he announced himself to Europe. Ireland hadn't won a rugby game in France in 28 years, and this French team had been to the World Cup semi final a year previously. Not much was expected of Ireland, but for those who don't already know what happened, I'll let the video tell the story.
O'Driscoll was about to lead a crop of talented youngsters, the likes of which Irish rugby had never seen before, through the golden generation. The wider world, and the southern hemisphere were announced to his attacking brilliance on the 2001 Lions tour to Australia.
Team Player
What makes Brian O'Driscoll different to all other outstanding players in any sport is his determination. His defensive play is the strength of his game, and his intelligence and knowledge of the game keep him ahead of everyone in attack. When someone as colossal as Paul O'Connell says about O'Driscoll, that he'd be the first person he'd want in the trenches beside him, you know it means something. O'Driscoll is never one to shirk a challenge, and always put his body on the line for Leinster and Ireland. He lead that generation up and made them believe that no longer were Ireland there just to make up numbers, but that they were good enough to win silverware.
It may have taken a long time, but in 2004, Ireland won their first Triple Crown in 19 years. That wasn't enough for O'Driscoll, as this was achieved again in 2006, and a third time in 2007. In 2007 though, there was a feeling of regret, because none of these Triple Crowns brought with it a 6 Nations title. But this was to come later. The Irish people were slowing being brought into the culture of rugby.
Genius
It's amazing to think that he is as good as he is, even though his eyesight is as bad as it is. Because his vision to see things that others don't is out of this world. Perhaps that would explain why some of these pieces of brilliance have happened.
Trophies
By 2009, the whole country was on the edge of their seats. Playing Wales in the deciding game of the 6 Nations had grown men crying, and non sporty women screaming. BOD was at the peak of his powers. 4 tries in the tournament; a combination of brilliant attacking running lines, defensive awareness and digging in the trenches, O'Driscoll inspired Ireland to the 6 Nations title and their first Grand Slam for 62 years.
A first Heineken Cup followed that year, and awards reigned down on Ireland's favourite son. The IRB award for player of the decade followed, giving you a hint at how highly he was regarded in the rugby world.
Still Got It
Despite claims that he's "past it" since 2009, O'Driscoll continued winning trophies, with two more Heineken Cups to follow in 2011 and 2012, while still producing the same magic that lit up our screens more than a decade ago. It takes a special kind of player to maintain the level of consistency required to reach 100 caps, and last weekend, Brian O'Driscoll broke the world record for the number of international rugby matches played in, at 140. This Saturday v France, will be his 141st and final appearance on the international stage.
Brian O'Driscoll: Finishing his career with an Irish record 46 tries and a world record 141 appearances.
The epitome of a Lion
It's a huge achievement to become a British and Irish Lion. To be considered one of the best in England, Scotland, Ireland and Wales is one of the top honours for a rugby player from those countries. A bigger achievement to do it twice. O'Driscoll is one of a very selective few who went on four tours - 2001, 2005, 2009 and 2013. Not only that, but he was selected as captain on the ill fated tour to New Zealand in 2005.
In each tour, you can get a glimpse of the character and talent of O'Driscoll. You've seen the wonderous try against Australia in 2001, but in 2009 he showed his toughness with a huge hit on the massive Danie Roussouw (below).
Add to that, the reaction of the public in 2005, when Tana Umaga and Kevin Mealamu spear tackled him in the first minute of the first test, breaking his collarbone tells you a lot about how he is viewed in the public. Perhaps more enlightening was the reaction to seeing him dropped from the deciding test in 2013.
Public Perception
Despite a few dodgy haircuts throughout the years, O'Driscoll is firmly held in a positive light throughout the world. His approachability, and humour paint him as a likable guy even without the strings of fame that come with dragging Irish rugby out of the doldrums.
Not only that, but his charity work sets him apart as a stand up guy, and when children like this say nice things about you then...
I guess there is nothing more to say than: Thank you Brian
Thursday 27 February 2014
Super Rugby Review Round 2: So Sharpe
It may say Round 2, but last week was the first proper week of Super Rugby. With all countries finally up and running, and 14 of the 15 teams having played at least one game, we are back in business.
And what a weekend. The early morning games between the Chiefs and Crusaders, and the Blues and Highlanders were two of the most entertaining games of the year. The Chiefs laid down a marker that it'll take a special team to deny them from a historic threepeat, while the Highlanders threatened to show that their season will be vastly improved from last year.
In other games, the Brumbies showed that the loss of Jake White will hamper them this season, losing to the Reds in a game that you sense would have gone their way last year; Israel Folau showed that he can get even better than last season with a fantastic performance. While the Lions shocked everyone (again) with another victory against a lacklustre Stormers team.
Some talented players have been introduced to us, with Marnitz Boshoff, Alofa Alofa, Kane Hames and Patrick Tuipulotu and Malakai Fekitoa showing that they have promising careers ahead of them.
In the fantasy leagues; Nathan Sharpe not only distanced himself from everyone, but is in the top 10 overall. Challenge extended.
And what a weekend. The early morning games between the Chiefs and Crusaders, and the Blues and Highlanders were two of the most entertaining games of the year. The Chiefs laid down a marker that it'll take a special team to deny them from a historic threepeat, while the Highlanders threatened to show that their season will be vastly improved from last year.
In other games, the Brumbies showed that the loss of Jake White will hamper them this season, losing to the Reds in a game that you sense would have gone their way last year; Israel Folau showed that he can get even better than last season with a fantastic performance. While the Lions shocked everyone (again) with another victory against a lacklustre Stormers team.
Some talented players have been introduced to us, with Marnitz Boshoff, Alofa Alofa, Kane Hames and Patrick Tuipulotu and Malakai Fekitoa showing that they have promising careers ahead of them.
In the fantasy leagues; Nathan Sharpe not only distanced himself from everyone, but is in the top 10 overall. Challenge extended.
All players had good results, with 2011, 2012 and 2013 Head to Head champion Cillian Hogan bringing himself back into the fold with a big score of 384 points. Other big scores came from Simon Farrell, William Kedjanyi and Calum Gilon improving their totals.
The head to head league had some interesting results, with Alex Shaw proving that he is 21 points better than average, and a number of matchs having both players with over 300 points.
Notable matchups next week include Alex Shaw v Garbhan Hogan, and Calum Gillon getting his chance to prove that he is better than normal.
Best of luck to everyone, let the trash talk begin.
Monday 17 February 2014
Super Rugby Review Round 1
It's back and bigger and better than ever before. Yes, the fantasy competition has finally kicked off after days of questionable marketing, this year's competition promises to be the most competitive, banterful and best yet. Oh, and the rugby wasn't too bad.
Cheetahs 20-21 Lions
The re-instated Lions are not expected to do much in this year's competition. Up until the 60th minute in this tie, they weren't expected to do much at all. Elgar Watts came on for the Cheetahs, and between some terrible placekicking and some basic errors, a long drop goal from 20 year old debutante Marnite Boshoff gave the Lions an unexpected win. The majority of their good play rested on the shoulders of their backrow, with Jaco Kriel carrying very well and Derek Minnie and Warren Whitely also performing well. In the backs, Lionel Mapoe gives Boshoff and outlet, and all five along with Springbok Franco van der Merwe will need big seasons in order to beat the performances of the Kings last season. It's hard to say what went wrong for the Cheetahs, with the backline looking impressive. Willie le Roux pulled the strings and created tries for both wingers. The pack needs to up it another gear to get back to last seasons form, while another game could iron out some of the mistakes that crept in. Johan Goosen finally got through a game, and his fitness will be vital to the Cheetahs playoff hopes.
Sharks 31-16 Bulls
Last season's Currie Cup was confirmation that with the unprecedented volume of departures from Loftus Versfeld, that the Bulls will struggle this season. The young team did well to stay competitive and in the game for as long as they did, but Pat Lambie's last minute try puts some gloss on the performance and gave the "Shorks" all five match points. For the "Shorks", it was a perfect opening to life under Jake White, and they will be hoping that Pat Lambie kicks on now that he has been given a position to make his own.
Dream Team
1. Julian Redelinghuys 22 LIONS
2. Adriaan Strauss 39 Cheetahs
3. Tendai Mtwararira 20 "SHORKS"
4. Franco van der Merwe 19 LIONS
5. Flip van der Merwe 15 BULLS
6. Marcell Coetzee 37 "SHORKS"
7. Lappies Labuschagne 31 CHEETAHS
8. Philip van der Walt 29 CHEETAHS
9. Cobus Reinach 30 "SHORKS"
10. Pat Lambie 44 "SHORKS"
11. Lwazi Mvovo 31 "SHORKS"
12. Francois Venter 22 CHEETAHS
13. Paul Jordaan 37 "SHORKS"
14. Cornal Hendricks 32 CHEETAHS
15. Willie le Roux 31 "CHEETAHS"
An intriguing dream team selection so far, with try scorers dominating the backline although creator Willie le Roux sneaks in ahead of Raymond Rhule. Workhorses feature in the pack, with Coetzee's 15 tackles earning him a lot of points, and the unheard of Julian Redelinghuys earning Football Manager gem status by not putting a foot wrong in earning the top prop spot for the week. With the rest of the competition starting this week, managers have to balance their teams carefully. A long way to go.
TwitterFight
A number of people have asked if it's too late to enter. A look at the table below will tell you. Places 3rd to 19th are still wide open. And the players in the head to head, but not classic can join the classic league with their current team and points too.
Cheetahs 20-21 Lions
The re-instated Lions are not expected to do much in this year's competition. Up until the 60th minute in this tie, they weren't expected to do much at all. Elgar Watts came on for the Cheetahs, and between some terrible placekicking and some basic errors, a long drop goal from 20 year old debutante Marnite Boshoff gave the Lions an unexpected win. The majority of their good play rested on the shoulders of their backrow, with Jaco Kriel carrying very well and Derek Minnie and Warren Whitely also performing well. In the backs, Lionel Mapoe gives Boshoff and outlet, and all five along with Springbok Franco van der Merwe will need big seasons in order to beat the performances of the Kings last season. It's hard to say what went wrong for the Cheetahs, with the backline looking impressive. Willie le Roux pulled the strings and created tries for both wingers. The pack needs to up it another gear to get back to last seasons form, while another game could iron out some of the mistakes that crept in. Johan Goosen finally got through a game, and his fitness will be vital to the Cheetahs playoff hopes.
Sharks 31-16 Bulls
Last season's Currie Cup was confirmation that with the unprecedented volume of departures from Loftus Versfeld, that the Bulls will struggle this season. The young team did well to stay competitive and in the game for as long as they did, but Pat Lambie's last minute try puts some gloss on the performance and gave the "Shorks" all five match points. For the "Shorks", it was a perfect opening to life under Jake White, and they will be hoping that Pat Lambie kicks on now that he has been given a position to make his own.
Dream Team
1. Julian Redelinghuys 22 LIONS
2. Adriaan Strauss 39 Cheetahs
3. Tendai Mtwararira 20 "SHORKS"
4. Franco van der Merwe 19 LIONS
5. Flip van der Merwe 15 BULLS
6. Marcell Coetzee 37 "SHORKS"
7. Lappies Labuschagne 31 CHEETAHS
8. Philip van der Walt 29 CHEETAHS
9. Cobus Reinach 30 "SHORKS"
10. Pat Lambie 44 "SHORKS"
11. Lwazi Mvovo 31 "SHORKS"
12. Francois Venter 22 CHEETAHS
13. Paul Jordaan 37 "SHORKS"
14. Cornal Hendricks 32 CHEETAHS
15. Willie le Roux 31 "CHEETAHS"
An intriguing dream team selection so far, with try scorers dominating the backline although creator Willie le Roux sneaks in ahead of Raymond Rhule. Workhorses feature in the pack, with Coetzee's 15 tackles earning him a lot of points, and the unheard of Julian Redelinghuys earning Football Manager gem status by not putting a foot wrong in earning the top prop spot for the week. With the rest of the competition starting this week, managers have to balance their teams carefully. A long way to go.
TwitterFight
A number of people have asked if it's too late to enter. A look at the table below will tell you. Places 3rd to 19th are still wide open. And the players in the head to head, but not classic can join the classic league with their current team and points too.
New entries here
Head to Head
Some intriguing fixtures thrown up already, with last year's champion falling to Alex Shaw sport (@alexshawsport), can he make it two in a row next week by proving he is better than average? While Cillian Hogan's Poseidon's Belvedere will be in "the trenches" with the competition leader.
A look at the table shows the beauty of head to head, with Northern Stereotype in 11th with 48 points ahead of DJ's army with 267 points in 12th possy.
The week is sure to be full of boasting, name calling and the occasional cry in the bathroom as #fantsbants moves to Round 2.
Monday 10 February 2014
First Timer's Guide to Fantasy Super Rugby
Tired of a boring Irish Times fantasy rugby that only rewards tries and man of the match performances? Are you already too far ahead or behind your competitors and seeking a new challenge? Super Rugby is starting soon, and the fantasy competition provided by foxsports.com.au is one of the best I've ever seen. Thinking of having a go? Here are some tips for the first time fantasy rugby player.
Look at the Rules first
(Provided below) Each fantasy competition is different, some reward points for tries and wins, others go into more detail. This is one of those competition. You wouldn't pick a world XV in a fantasy team geared towards tries, just like you don't pick a fantasy team solely to get tries for this fantasy.
Work Rate is key
Players who work hard, who make lots of tackles and lots of runs, the points add up quickly and are worthy additions to your team. Northern Hemisphere equivalents could be Courtney Lawes, Dan Lydiate or Theirry Dusautoir, players who work hard but never score tries. These players would consistently bring points.
Avoid Centres and Scrumhalves
Centres and Scrumhalves are traditionally the lowest scoring positions in the competition. Don't waste valuable budget money on getting expensive ones. Best served elsewhere
Players who play out of position
Players like Steven Luatua last year, who was down as a lock, but played as a blindside flanker, earned huge points as a second row. There is usually one player who plays several positions, and different positions generally give more points.
Pick Players who actually play
Actions occurring in extra time count towards points scored. Points are awarded as set out in the table below:
Action Points
Look at the Rules first
(Provided below) Each fantasy competition is different, some reward points for tries and wins, others go into more detail. This is one of those competition. You wouldn't pick a world XV in a fantasy team geared towards tries, just like you don't pick a fantasy team solely to get tries for this fantasy.
Work Rate is key
Players who work hard, who make lots of tackles and lots of runs, the points add up quickly and are worthy additions to your team. Northern Hemisphere equivalents could be Courtney Lawes, Dan Lydiate or Theirry Dusautoir, players who work hard but never score tries. These players would consistently bring points.
Avoid Centres and Scrumhalves
Centres and Scrumhalves are traditionally the lowest scoring positions in the competition. Don't waste valuable budget money on getting expensive ones. Best served elsewhere
Players who play out of position
Players like Steven Luatua last year, who was down as a lock, but played as a blindside flanker, earned huge points as a second row. There is usually one player who plays several positions, and different positions generally give more points.
Pick Players who actually play
Crucial. The biggest problem for team owners is managing the schedule. Not every team plays every week. Plus the comp is long; at 16 weeks plus finals, players will be rotated in and out. You have to make sure that you have 15 guys earning you points every single week. Look ahead at the fixture list and try to avoid obvious conflicts early.
Also beware of picking the big stars, especially in New Zealand. Do you really want to pick Richie McCaw or Kieran Read when they’re likely to be put in cotton wool at the slightest hint of injury? Instead that money might be better spent on someone like Michael Hooper, who will play 80 minutes nearly all season long. Similarly, I’d be pretty wary about picking either Bernard Foley or Kurtley Beale until you get some sense of who’s going to be starting; you’d have to doubt that either of them will be playing a full match every week just at the moment.
Also beware of picking the big stars, especially in New Zealand. Do you really want to pick Richie McCaw or Kieran Read when they’re likely to be put in cotton wool at the slightest hint of injury? Instead that money might be better spent on someone like Michael Hooper, who will play 80 minutes nearly all season long. Similarly, I’d be pretty wary about picking either Bernard Foley or Kurtley Beale until you get some sense of who’s going to be starting; you’d have to doubt that either of them will be playing a full match every week just at the moment.
Don't avoid weak teams
This competition is ultra competitive, that just because a team is miles down the table doesn't mean they don't have fantasy gems. Ben Smith was a banker last season for the underperforming Highlanders, while Ged Robinson gained huge points playing for the Rebels. (Robinson has since left the Rebels).
Value over Replacement
While Israel Folau is nearly guaranteed to get you mega points, it'll definitely cost you mega bucks. It might be worth going for someone less expensive who could still rake in the points. Some positions have more points depth than others. It's all about what works for you.
FANTASY RULES
During the 2014 Super Rugby season, the players will be allocated a Fantasy point score after each match, based on their performances in the 2014 Super Rugby matches and the scoring system below. Only player performances in official 2014 Super Rugby matches are included in the scoring for Fantasy Super Rugby. The Fantasy points will be calculated using statistics supplied by the Promoter's data provider. The Promoter will not enter into any correspondence relating to the allocation of Fantasy points to players. The Promoter accepts no responsibility for the accuracy of this data and the Promoter's decision is final and binding.
Actions occurring in extra time count towards points scored. Points are awarded as set out in the table below:
Action Points
Playing 1 - 60 minutes 1
Props that play more than 60 minutes 4
Hookers, locks and backrowers that play more than 61 minutes 3
All other positions playing more than 61 minutes 2
For each try scored by a prop or hooker 15
For each try scored by a lock or backrower 12
For each try scored by a scrum-half, fly-half, centre or outside back 10
For each try assist 5
For each try save 5
For each conversion 2
For each conversion miss -1
For each penalty goal 3
For each penalty miss -1
For each drop goal 3
For each drop goal miss -1
Yellow card -5
Red card -15
For each run 1
For each tackle bust 2
For each offload 1
For each linebreak 5
For each linebreak creates 3
For each error -3
For each tackle made by a prop or hooker 2
For each tackle made by all other positions 1
For each tackle miss -2
For each lineout take on own throw 1
For each lineout steal on opposition throw 4
For each lineout error, includes not straight, throw error or jump error -3
For each tight head won, awarded to entire front row 7
For each tight head lost, awarded to entire front row -3
For each pilfer 4
For each turn over forced 3
For each penalty - long arm -4
Join Now
Head to Head League 7255-5069
Normal League 7255-5068
Props that play more than 60 minutes 4
Hookers, locks and backrowers that play more than 61 minutes 3
All other positions playing more than 61 minutes 2
For each try scored by a prop or hooker 15
For each try scored by a lock or backrower 12
For each try scored by a scrum-half, fly-half, centre or outside back 10
For each try assist 5
For each try save 5
For each conversion 2
For each conversion miss -1
For each penalty goal 3
For each penalty miss -1
For each drop goal 3
For each drop goal miss -1
Yellow card -5
Red card -15
For each run 1
For each tackle bust 2
For each offload 1
For each linebreak 5
For each linebreak creates 3
For each error -3
For each tackle made by a prop or hooker 2
For each tackle made by all other positions 1
For each tackle miss -2
For each lineout take on own throw 1
For each lineout steal on opposition throw 4
For each lineout error, includes not straight, throw error or jump error -3
For each tight head won, awarded to entire front row 7
For each tight head lost, awarded to entire front row -3
For each pilfer 4
For each turn over forced 3
For each penalty - long arm -4
Join Now
Head to Head League 7255-5069
Normal League 7255-5068
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)